Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism.

04-12-2013 , 11:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
I was just giving one example. The anti-theist atheists want to live a hedonistic life without being reminded that it's wrong. Better atheists recognise and respect the good there is in religion so they defend it rather than trying to tear it down.
Can you name anything that you think is good that can only come from religion or because a person is religious?
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-13-2013 , 04:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
I was just giving one example. The anti-theist atheists want to live a hedonistic life without being reminded that it's wrong. Better atheists recognize and respect the good there is in religion so they defend it rather than trying to tear it down.
I don't think religious asceticism is necessarily a good thing. And I don't respect religion for shaming people with imaginary places of eternal torture to do it. And no, not all anti theists are hedonistic, I think I've said that a couple times already.

Last edited by Huehuecoyotl; 04-13-2013 at 04:13 AM.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-13-2013 , 05:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Huehuecoyotl
I don't think religious asceticism is necessarily a good thing. And I don't respect religion for shaming people with imaginary places of eternal torture to do it. And no, not all anti theists are hedonistic, I think I've said that a couple times already.
For atheists the "imaginary" places can be thought of as metaphorical. They create their own heaven or hell for themselves and others. So you see God is relevant to them as well. With religious values we are dealing with perfection and of course none of us are perfect nor are we completely evil. The following are undesirable quaities and we should curb them in ourselves.

Lust
Gluttony
Greed
Sloth
Wrath
Envy
Pride
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-13-2013 , 11:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
For atheists the "imaginary" places can be thought of as metaphorical. They create their own heaven or hell for themselves and others. So you see God is relevant to them as well. With religious values we are dealing with perfection and of course none of us are perfect nor are we completely evil. The following are undesirable quaities and we should curb them in ourselves.

Lust
Gluttony
Greed
Sloth
Wrath
Envy
Pride
Except that's not how the religious see it. It's not a metaphor to them, nor to the children whom they indoctrinate. It's an actual real place. If my friend said he saw UFOs I wouldn't try to translate it into a metaphor.

You forgot to add Stupidity to your list.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 12:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Huehuecoyotl
Except that's not how the religious see it. It's not a metaphor to them, nor to the children whom they indoctrinate. It's an actual real place. If my friend said he saw UFOs I wouldn't try to translate it into a metaphor.

You forgot to add Stupidity to your list.
Lol.
No he forgot reason. That's a sin for theist
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 10:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kurto
I'm an atheist and I have a lot of gay friends. I see religion as an impediment to gay people's civil rights. Is it irrational to take issue with religion's role in the oppression of gays, women, etc.?

I believe education of children is important. I believe that religion groups in the US are dumbing down our educational system due to their fear of science. Am I being irrational for attacking the role of religion in screwing with the education of our children?

I have to admit I have no understanding of Cwocwoc's posts or how he thinks his position is derived rationally.
Religion is about perfect behaviour not about allowing all kinds of things. It may not be for you although you should make the effort where you feel you can. Your complaints about education are very trivial. It makes little difference whether or not "evolution" is taught in schools. Nobody really understands that theory anyway. eg with giraffes why didn't their stomachs evolve into being able to digest low-hanging food or stuff on the ground ? Darwin just made it up as he went along.

I have noticed that the people who fixate on things to hate often have more deep-seated problems in their own lives and use attacking religion etc as an inappropriate form of cathartic self-therapy. I am content so I am chilled out about religion and iimmigration and stuff like that.

Last edited by Cwocwoc; 04-14-2013 at 10:08 AM.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 12:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
Religion is about perfect behaviour not about allowing all kinds of things. It may not be for you although you should make the effort where you feel you can. Your complaints about education are very trivial. It makes little difference whether or not "evolution" is taught in schools. Nobody really understands that theory anyway. eg with giraffes why didn't their stomachs evolve into being able to digest low-hanging food or stuff on the ground ? Darwin just made it up as he went along.

I have noticed that the people who fixate on things to hate often have more deep-seated problems in their own lives and use attacking religion etc as an inappropriate form of cathartic self-therapy. I am content so I am chilled out about religion and iimmigration and stuff like that.
Confimed troll.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 12:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Husker
Confimed troll.
Ho hum my stalking WUM returns. Have you anything to contribute to this discussion ? Whether or not evolution is taught does not affect the overall quality of the education. It has nothing to do with most of the subjects that are taught.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 01:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ganstaman



Because there's a lot of people trying to force their notion of God and religion on everyone else. At least in the US, where there are people who, due to their religious beliefs, want to ban gambling, teach creationism as science, trample on gay rights, prosecute those who seek abortion, etc, I think it's fairly obvious why an atheist (or otherwise reasonable theist) who want to get involved in these religious discussions since it does have a real impact on their lives.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
A lot of those things are not religious. A lot of atheists see gambling as a vice and want to define gay rights strictly.
If those things are not religious and those are the things most new atheists are critical of, then it means most new atheists are not attacking religion. Problem solved.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 02:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
Religion is about perfect behaviour not about allowing all kinds of things. It may not be for you although you should make the effort where you feel you can. Your complaints about education are very trivial. It makes little difference whether or not "evolution" is taught in schools. Nobody really understands that theory anyway. eg with giraffes why didn't their stomachs evolve into being able to digest low-hanging food or stuff on the ground ? Darwin just made it up as he went along.

I have noticed that the people who fixate on things to hate often have more deep-seated problems in their own lives and use attacking religion etc as an inappropriate form of cathartic self-therapy. I am content so I am chilled out about religion and iimmigration and stuff like that.
Confirmed Troll
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 02:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Huehuecoyotl
Except that's not how the religious see it. It's not a metaphor to them, nor to the children whom they indoctrinate. It's an actual real place. If my friend said he saw UFOs I wouldn't try to translate it into a metaphor.

You forgot to add Stupidity to your list.
"For atheists"

What part of "for atheists" don't you understand ? I am showing how the morality to be found in religions is also relevant to atheists. The atheist humanists had no problem accepting this when they published their first manifesto. Unfortunately too many modern atheists appear to be more interested in attacking religion than in working out how to live decently and rationality can have no part in that particular crusade.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 05:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
Ho hum my stalking WUM returns. Have you anything to contribute to this discussion ? Whether or not evolution is taught does not affect the overall quality of the education. It has nothing to do with most of the subjects that are taught.
Stalking? I think if you review your posts you'll find I've had the good sense to avoid them. I'm not missing anything of substance.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 05:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Husker
Stalking? I think if you review your posts you'll find I've had the good sense to avoid them. I'm not missing anything of substance.
"Have you anything to contribute to this discussion ?"

I'll take that as a "No" then.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 05:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
Your complaints about education are very trivial. It makes little difference whether or not "evolution" is taught in schools.
Evolution is very important to learn about as it has great impact on our lives and it helps demonstrate the scientific process. It is also useful for helping kids learn how to think. I would say that education that ignores evolution is not a very good education.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
Nobody really understands that theory anyway. eg with giraffes why didn't their stomachs evolve into being able to digest low-hanging food or stuff on the ground ? Darwin just made it up as he went along.
Maybe you don't understand the theory, which would explain the rest of this quote, but many of us do actually have a decent grasp on it.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 06:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ganstaman
Evolution is very important to learn about as it has great impact on our lives and it helps demonstrate the scientific process. It is also useful for helping kids learn how to think. I would say that education that ignores evolution is not a very good education.



Maybe you don't understand the theory, which would explain the rest of this quote, but many of us do actually have a decent grasp on it.
It is a tiny part of any education. No-one understands the theory properly. Where are the half-men half-monkeys (the missing link) ? They've been looking for years without success
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 06:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
It is a tiny part of any education. No-one understands the theory properly. Where are the half-men half-monkeys (the missing link) ? They've been looking for years without success
Are you ****ing kidding me? [Obvious troll is obvious?]
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 06:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by asdfasdf32
Are you ****ing kidding me? [Obvious troll is obvious?]
That's the trouble with you people who treat atheism like a fundamentalist religion ; no sense of humour. Someone asks which is the worst religion elsewhere. Well it's proseletysing atheism.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 06:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
That's the trouble with you people who treat atheism like a fundamentalist religion ; no sense of humour. Someone asks which is the worst religion elsewhere. Well it's proseletysing atheism.
Now you're claiming you were joking? Mmmkay.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 06:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by asdfasdf32
Now you're claiming you were joking? Mmmkay.
Of course I was joking. I have seen monkeys smoking pipes and men eating bananas.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 06:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cwocwoc
Of course I was joking. I have seen monkeys smoking pipes and men eating bananas.
Mmmkay.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 06:57 PM
It always amazes me how little evolution deniers know about the subject. If I was going to make it my hobby to go online and pretend that evolution isn't a proven fact, I would at least take the hour or two it needs to become moderately conversant with how it works. Still, I suppose "Proud To Be Ignorant" is a good motto for creationists.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 07:04 PM
I think at some point we just all have to stop replying to him.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 07:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by zumby
I think at some point we just all have to stop replying to him.
Yeah.
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 07:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr Beer
It always amazes me how little evolution deniers know about the subject. If I was going to make it my hobby to go online and pretend that evolution isn't a proven fact, I would at least take the hour or two it needs to become moderately conversant with how it works. Still, I suppose "Proud To Be Ignorant" is a good motto for creationists.

I don't deny it I just deny that not teaching evolution "dumbs down" anyone's overall education significantly.


I am not surprised that the atheists on here don't like morality judging by their posts. I'd question what they're doing on here if they are not religious or interested in moral issues. This forum is for "Discussion of God, religion, faith, theology, and spirituality" not for cr*pping on those who want to discuss those things..
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote
04-14-2013 , 07:52 PM
Trying so hard to take zumby's advice...
What is the difference between genuine Atheism and New Atheism. Quote

      
m