Quote:
Originally Posted by madrobin
To say that masks are useless is absurd.
To try to construct some alternate reality based on yes, cherry-picking data to support that premise, is intellectually dishonest.
To demand that anyone objecting to the statement that masks are useless provide "hundreds" of studies as proof of that is foolish.
To make an absurd claim and then try to support it by utterly ignoring the fundamentals of statistical analysis, such as adjusting for variables and correlations, is the stuff of TV pundits and late-night talk radio.
To make a statement that directly contradicts the statements of tens of thousands of experts in the field is a show of extreme hubris as well as a grossly exaggerated sense of the importance of one's opinion.
To shout at and belittle someone else because they DARE to challenge your pronouncements that the sun is green and pigs fly is the behavior of an anal orifice.
PFR did not ask for someone to post the hundreds of studies showing masks efficacy until that person claimed PFR was cherry picking from hundreds of studies. If you or someone want to claim PFR is cherry picking data, you need to post some links to all this plentiful counter data. PFR at least posted the data.
Similarly if you wish to claim support from tens of thous@nds of experts you need to cite a fair number of them. There are many other experts who disagree. Just because they disagree with your position does not make them kooks, crackpots or even non experts which has been a common tactic of yours.
Reality is that good N95 and maybe even some KN95 masks worn consistently and correctly probably had some moderate efficacy against early variants. But those masks were never in the us in widespread, proper use. And it was not just the anti mask and or anti vaccine crowd causing this. Just look at the Congress masker in chief Ms. Pelosi. She loves to run around in public with those stylish, poor fitting, useless cloth masks
But even if suddenly everyone was wearing good, proper fitting masks Delta changes things. If such masks were merderately effective with a spread ratio of 3, now that Delta spread ratio is 6 - 9 those masks will have minimal efficacy.
Btw, me personally I wear masks always when required and sometimes when not required. I also own a few N95 masks that I often but not always use. Since my daughter actually intubated many dozens of covid positive patients, she was trained in how to resterilize her very limited number of N95 masks early in the pandemic and shared how with me. Also I have over 30 years of being fit tested for full and half face respirators, 30 years of SCBA training (as well as being a recreational scuba diver). I know when a mask fits, how to adjust them, which ones should fit me and how to care for them. So I am far from anti mask.
As to the van, I scheduled my first jab within five minutes of when I was eligible through my employer. I will get my booster as soon as I can. Plus there is a decent chance I recently had a breakthrough case of covid. Did not get tested since symptoms were extremely mild and I was already isolated I just made sure to keep isolating until 72 hours past all symptoms.
But I am still willing to admit that mask mandates as imposed are likely to have minimal impact. Not worthless but also not a solution. The reality is that covid is now likely just another endemic illness like colds and flu. Most will initially catch it as a child and carry some level of immunity for the rest of their life. They will occasionally get reinfected but for the vast majority their prior immunity will make each case minor or even less. We might eventually vaccinate young kids with booster throughout their lives. But it is very unlikely to disappear. Also unlikely to remain a plague like scourge forever.