Quote:
Originally Posted by Mike Johnson
Size has nothing to do with. The WSOP is 100x bigger than the EPL will ever be and they don't have an ethics committee. You need to differentiate between gambling/poker ethics in general and an 'ethics committee' that meets and discusses players personal life.
What I'm saying is the EPL doesn't need an 'ethics committee'. That's very different than saying a casino shouldn't expect their customers to act ethically. Casinos have always had the power to remove someone from their property/games for any reason they see fit. They don't need a committee made of up players from the league(not casino executives) deciding based on vague, ambiguous guidelines who is and isn't worthy.
If the casino doesn't want you playing for any reason, you don't play. It's always been that way. The WSOP, EPT and other major poker tours all expect their players to be ethical from a gambling and behavior standpoint and will act accordingly if not, but they certainly don't feel it necessary to dig into peoples personal lives to determine if they are worthy of placing a bet.
I completely agree size doesn't matter but you did bring up the sizes of FT and EPL not me, which is why I made the comment/asked the question.
I've had a quick scan thru your posts in the NVG thread and I agree with you on all points apart the fact the ethics committee shouldn't exist. If the owners/executives of the EPL want to run a whiter than white league then an ethics committee would be useful. It is clearly very flawed at the moment but if they can solve its problems then there is no reason it shouldn't exist.
If any league or tournament series, WSOP, EPT, EPL, etc, wants to have a rule stating "if you fit these criteria you will only have your buy-in refunded" and it is clearly stated before the tournament starts then an independent (Annie Duke or any other EPL owners/executives should not be part of it) open ethics committee surely has to be better than it being dealt with behind closed doors by sort of security team, at the whim of those with a vested interest. All poker leagues and tournaments series have a team of people to enforce the rules of the tournament. The EPL has decided to do this with the "Epic Poker Standards & Conduct Committee" and if it can be properly implemented I think its preferable than other current methods.