Quote:
Originally Posted by tzwien
I just found this thread and have only read the OP, but as a .8 handicap I can very confidently say I would never ever be able to finish this in a single day. The "x out of x" drills are achievable, but the "x in a row" just aren't possible for me. I don't get why some drills are so easy to complete and some are impossible. 4 out of 10 on the green with a 5 iron compared to 20 in a row inside 3 feet from 45 feet at varying locations? The 5 iron equivalent to that putting drill should be like 15/20 on the green.
But the idea of the routine is what counts, to get people out there working on something useful instead of just slapping the ball around on the range. Though I do find it hard to believe many people could actually complete this routine in 1.5 to 2 hours, no matter how damn good they are.
I completely understand your thoughts, and I thought I'd share my thought process in making the putting 25/25 as opposed to a % of success. I believe putting is the one area where anyone can become proficient. Most players will never hit it 300 yards, they just don't have the flexibility, strength, or ability to hit it that far. However, putting takes no strength, you can be male or female, young or old, and develop relatively good putting skills. I think if the average player wants to improve, putting is a great place to start, but I placed the bar pretty high because I wanted to develop true consistency and with that, increased confidence. As a good player, I'm sure you've been around some tour-caliber players - if you watched a tour player roll putts on a relatively flat putting green, they could probably roll 100/100 inside 3 feet of the hole from 20, 30, 40, feet - their touch is so developed & precise. I don't expect the average player to have the touch of a PGA Tour player, but I didn't want the variance factor -- hit 10 inside 3 feet, but 4 other putts 6 or 7 feet away - which leads to inconsistency & 3-putts.
I know it seems that some of the areas are pretty difficult, but I think as a low handicap player, you might actually find the routine too
easy if you give it a try. Unless there is a significant weakness in a certain area. When the Georgia Tech golf team began using the routine, Nicholas Thompson hated it - at the time, he was one of the best ball strikers in college, but his putting was nowhere near the level of his ball striking. He despised the putting because he couldn't do it at first. Once we made some changes in his stroke and he improved his putting, he didn't really mind it & could complete it easily.
FWIW, I do the putting part of the routine 3-4 times per week over my lunch hour & it takes me around 30-40 minutes to complete. I don't really get to practice much, so I don't get the time to do the whole routine, but I try to make the time for the putting either over lunch or before I begin my day. I think if you try it, you'd be surprised at how quickly you could complete it (barring a specific weakness). Give it a shot if you can & let me know your thoughts - also, since you mentioned you didn't get a chance to read the entire thread, I mention that players are encouraged to adjust the numbers to suit their desired goals, so feel free to change it for your individual needs.
Thanks for the feedback - let me know if you try it & your thoughts!