Quote:
Originally Posted by REDeYeS00
PokerHero,
I'm not going to derail this thread past this post, but what you think is a linksland course seems to be just the opposite.
every hole on Kiawah Ocean was bulldozed by Dye to its current shape. there's almost nothing linksland (natural) about it.
same thing goes for Chamber's Bay. that course was built upon a former sand and gravel pit and 1.4 million cubic yards of sand and dirt were removed from the course, cleaned, and returned to shape the course.
Bandon Dunes, Pacific Dunes, and Old MacDonald are recognized as three of the five true links courses in North America, along with Highland Links in MA and Cabot Links in NS. https://migrantgolfer.com/the-true-l...-of-the-world/
this list uses the British Golf Museum's criteria for what a true links course is. please let me know if you think their interpretation is incorrect.
Whistling Straits trucked in how much sand, a million tons? I don't understand what that has to do with anything.
And Bandon Dunes is basically 100% clay soil. How that satisfies qualification for a "links" course is kinda weird.
Bandon Dunes is also situated on cliffs. How is that linksland? At least Kiawah is sandy at sea level with routing resembling a links course.
I get it, you like Bandon Dunes. I'm not knocking it per se, just asserting that most US golfers weight conditions, visuals, and playability/challenge highly, and Moonlight appears to check all the boxes.