Quote:
Originally Posted by Thremp
Lemme get this straight, a comic book character who is on a quest for vengeance where he mercilessly kills everyone who participated in the experiment that creates him, saves a young girl and then kindaps her before engaging in a multi-month torture program to train her as his replacement, and generally destroys everything else is a paradigm of good? Or merely just a good character instead of the standard "ends justify the means" neutral? I suggest you review your copy of the comic, and the alignment checks for your preferred flavor of Dungeons and Dragons.
If your perception of it is that one-dimensional, then you truly are ******ed. I think we both know, however, that you don't ACTUALLY believe that is all it boils down to; I mean cmon your previous post was calling him "chaotic NEUTRAL." That is just about the WORST description possible.
Killing people who participated in an almost Nazi-like regime?? Yeah, definitely not good...
Setting Evey free? Something that she is, ultimately, thankful for? Yeah, DEFINITELY not good...
I mean you seriously must have read the 2 sentence plot on IMDB or something, given your lack of understanding here.
Quote:
In addition, your 2nd quote mentions nothing of good. It only speaks of order. The two are entirely unrelated.
The way your previous post was worded made it sound like because he was an anarchist meant he couldn't be good, and that it automatically classified him as "chaotic neutral" instead of "chaotic good". I am not sure what you would consider wanting a "voluntary orderly society" as opposed to the one that was in place, but I would consider it good. If he was neutral, he would have just created chaos for the sake of it - regardless of what side it affected - instead of trying to fix everything. Work on your writing coherence if you don't want people to set you straight with stuff that you (supposedly) already know...
Quote:
Please get through the Surridge killing without an alignment check as a good character under anyone competent.
Yeah, the one person that felt bad about everything they had done? Good thing he made her suffer through suchhhhh a horrrrrrrrribly painful death! Oh, wait...
You just don't get it, and you probably never will. Adios, sucker! Say hi to this "teagan" character for me!
Wait seriously? there is no way you actually believe any of what you are saying.. I mean, NEUTRAL??? He picked a SIDE!! (the side of good, btw)
Last edited by Cmoneymaker9; 06-16-2009 at 07:54 PM.