Quote:
Originally Posted by loco
In the history of mankind the only people that having been able to lose weight and keep it off, have all exercised.
Maybe, but I'm talking about maximizing her gains per unit of effort put in right now. The more absolute effort she puts in, the harder it will be for her to stick to. At this stage of the game she stands to achieve more through diet than exercise, so she should focus on that more, while building the foundations for the exercise regime that she will be doing a year from now to keep the weight off. For me, this would entail walking a track 30 minutes per day at first, and escalating the length of that walk, and eventually the frequency and intensity. But that's going to constitute a tiny percentage of her deficit at first, so diet reigns supreme.
You might have a point that 1400 is extreme, but OP's goals are fairly extreme. It is tough for a female to lose almost 3 pounds per week the way she wants to. Not possible at 1800-2000. I'd say that 1400 is less extreme for a female than it is for a male of the same height, who would have higher energy needs. I've done 1600/day for the last 3 months and I eat very well, averaging over 100g protein a day, going out to eat at restaurants constantly. It just requires paying attention.