Quote:
Originally Posted by 00Snitch
cha, I've been wondering something about your dls for a while...
It seems like you have very similar form for both your trapbar and conventional deadlifts.
What I'm doing with the TBDLs is getting my hips back as far as possible so the hams & glutes are tight at the start of the pull. This does appear to be carrying over to my conventional DLs very well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 00Snitch
It's my understanding (possibly incorrect?) that TBDL is more quad dominant and really a bit more like a squat. And looking at your deads, they do look quite "squattish" to me.
naw, I'm most definitely posterior chain dominant when I DL. My hips start lower than yours because my hamstrings are shorter & tighter, and stronger.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 00Snitch
So by extension, it sesms that your conventional deadlift is more quad dominant than back and is that intentional on your part? Perhaps for mitigating risk of back injury or just because your quads are stronger so you can lift more?
Dont look at it as back dominant. You're thinking about it wrong.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 00Snitch
I'm kind of wondering because I've been watching your vids while I've been trying to improve my deadlift form and compared to you, I think my deadlift is more back dominant. I think I get far more horizontal (more acute hip angle).
Your problems are not because you're "back dominant". You're using your back too much because your back rounds because your abs and glutes and hamstrings are weak. That's what you need to get strong.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 00Snitch
And I think the real reason I am asking this, is from an overall "strength/muscle balance" point of view, if I'm squatting and deadlifting with the same regularity and relative strength (not saying I am personally), is there a problem with having a back dominant deadlift?
Yes, if you're pulling DLs with your low back muscles, you're doing them wrong. That's why I want to see you doing more light speed pulls to groove your form and get used to using the right muscles.
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Yugoslavian
Cha's DLs look the opposite of squattish though....at leaest to me.
There are some good lifters who pull wih higher hips than me, but you're right. I dont squat my DLs. They start with my posterior chain (hams & glutes).
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Yugoslavian
I do agree he sets up for TBDL very similarly but I think that is likely fine.
yup
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Yugoslavian
The problem with having a back dominant lift isn't that it's more of a back dominant lift, it's that if you aren't keeping your back really tight and keeping it from rounding or extension - then it will be harmful long-term.
Not only that, but if you aren't using the right muscles to get tight, your back is being subjected to lots of shear force, which is very bad. Also, dont even think about making your low back tight. Make your abs tight and fill your belly with air. When you do that right, your back should not move at all. Keep the pelvis locked to the rib cage.
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Yugoslavian
....... Compare my DL with Cha's - my butt sits much higher and is more back dominant. That's the way I'm built....but I keep my back tight and I've also been working more and more on keeping my shins as vertical as I can and rounding my shoulders so I can get a bit more length on my arms (I have a long torso and not long arms, which isn't very ideal for conventional DL).
Anyway, what I'm trying to say is there is no problem as long as you learn to DL safely consistently.
You're partially right, but your hips will start lower and not rise faster than your back when your glutes & hamstrings get stronger. The difference between you & Snitch is your core is stronger, which helps you keep your back from rounding as much.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 00Snitch
Yeah, I think that is mostly what I was asking. Although I think the 2nd part of my question is: "should" (subjective, I know) the deadlift be more back or legs?
It should be glutes & hams primarily for most people, including you. Then lats & upper back. When you eventually get the glutes & hams & abs very strong and start doing them right, you will hardly feel your low back doing anything, even during very heavy DLs.
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Yugoslavian
I'm pretty sure it depends on how the individual is built. There are super strong DLers from both styles. But none of them routinely let their low back go to **** on reps.
This is somewhat true. But its not only build. Ed Coan "squatted" something like an 875 lb conventional DL, and later sumo'ed a 900 lb DL using his glutes & hams. He had the skill to do it either way.
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Yugoslavian
I think part of my issue learning to DL is that there are several setups, several ways to get your back angle, etc. and they all may be "correct" but for ppl with different body ratios. Bench, OHP, and LBBS are all kind of the same for everyone (well, I guess squats can be affected quite a bit but not nearly as much as DLs)....but it seems to me DL has the most "wiggle-room" depending on your torso/arm/leg ratio.
I am starting to think a lot of people are too concerned about their body type with regards to form instead of thinking about strengthening their weaknesses.
Yugo - you need to keep hammering your form and working on glute & ham strength. That will keep your hips lower at the start of the pull.
Snitch - you need to hammer your form at light weights, focusing on getting your glutes & hams involved every time you pull. You also need to strengthen your weak core.
When you get your glutes & hams strong and get your setup down right, you should feel the tension in your glutes & hams before the weight leaves the ground. They should be wound up tight like big springs. That makes big weights fly off the ground and it protects your low back.