Quote:
Originally Posted by pkrplyrX
So Lyle said no one gains strength that fast, then he was proven wrong by the squat videos. 100% wrong. Has he made a claim that can be proven wrong wrt LBM gains? All I saw was that he said Zach could have gained more than 6 lbs of LBM (which I guess is based on Lyle's general expectation of 1 lb of LBM/month for men who aren't on roids), but certainly not 33 lbs. Based on that if Lyle goes to WFAC and uses a strict method of measuring and determines Zach only gained 20 lbs of LBM he can go "See, told you so, not 33 lbs!"
no claim, but you have to realize it is insane of you to NOT care that the claimed 46 (not 33) pounds of lbm in 6 months could be 30 or 35 just because it would still beat lyle's 2b/month (which again, is not concrete) by a good factor.
i see where lyle was coming from with the "rip can do no wrong" stuff. rip really ventured out of his element with the lbm claims, and it is frustrating that he did so without very solid proof, especially when a dexa scan is like $250. a single caliper test just doesn't cut it, even in the hands of the almighty.