Beer Advocate is a really good site, but their ratings are very biased towards high alcohol beers like the strong Belgians, the Russian Imperial, and barley-wine type beers. Those are all okay, but I'd like to see a wider spectrum/balance of ratings.
Young's Double Chocolate is good but I much prefer Young's Oatmeal - still thick and rich but not so sweet, and then Samuel Smith's Oatmeal is better than Young's Oatmeal.
BTW if you live in Austin, the "Draught House" is a great place for beers, all their house-made stuff is excellent but I love their Vanilla Porter.