Recently went to a dinner party and brought some beers:
My thoughts, right to left:
Gold Legacy - Wolf's Ridge is a local Columbus, OH brewery, and they just kill it. Probably my favorite local brewer (plus they have great food). This is opaquely described as a barrel-aged sour, and it's fantastic. This was my favorite beer of the night, and even non-sour people enjoyed it.
Dire Wolf Coffee Joy - Another Wolf's Ridge bottle, this one is a non-barrel aged stout that very much tasted like an Almond Joy. I love Almond Joy, so I enjoyed the beer. But it was a little too syrupy to drink much of. So I had a small amount, but fortunately several other people liked it and killed the bottle.
3 Foyds Behemoth - A barleywine that's been sitting around my basement forever. The first sip tasted great, but was just too thick and syrupy to drink much of. Like the prior bottle, I'm glad there were other people who liked the sweetness and killed the bottle.
Fantome Magic Ghost - Holy cow. Fantome beers in general are wild, and I never know what to expect. My most common experience when drinking a bottle is, "Wow, this tastes bad. I can't believe I bought this." Then, after a half glass, "Hmm, this isn't too bad." Then, at about 1/3 to 1/2 of the bottle, "Yes, I am definitely digging this." In short, Fantome beers are actually pretty great if you can make it through the first couple of tastes, but the variance is huge.
Anyway, this was green. Seriously, this was the first glass:
And if that's not green enough, this was the last glass:
It was a typical Fantome experience, where I ended up enjoying it much more at the end that at the beginning. But it's not close to the best bottles I've had. This is flavored with green tea, and it just didn't do much for me. I'll continue to buy Fantome, but not this bottle.
Rodenbach Alexander - I'm pretty sure I've shared this bottle with this group before, and exactly the same thing happend this time - everyone (wives and husbands both) loved it. I barely got any. This is not super complex, but it's a great way to end the night.
(I left the bottle of BCBS with the hosts - they like bourbon stouts. I assume it tasted like BCBS typically does.)