Quote:
Originally Posted by spivey
Beer nerdery these days seems all about pastry stouts with low bottle counts, despite the fact most of these breweries couldn't brew and barrel age a base stout beer that even approaches BCBS.
I agree with the first part, all the low bottle counts drive the values up incredibly high.
The 2nd part I find to be hit or miss. When they hit, some of those BA stouts (pastry or not) are incredible, some of the best beer I've had. Recently, Side Project's Derivations, the two I had might be the best two stouts I've ever had (no pastry there though). When they miss it's awful. In either case I find myself scratching my head on why people would wait overnight or spend several hundred dollars on the bottles.
I like BCBS a lot too, but I've noticed (coincidence or not) that some of the recent BA stouts I've had that I prefer over it have some oats in them and, a lot of chocolate malts and were barrel aged for 12-18 months before being blended (I'd imagine BCBS is 12 months and then it's blended, but no oats there and not a chocolate bomb. The recipe is public, or at least an iteration of it from the last few years).