Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
The Beer connoisseur thread The Beer connoisseur thread

01-08-2018 , 11:26 PM
For my money Speedway Stout is the best regularly available stout in the market. If there are any CA people here let me know as I’m always in search of their variants. Love me some Hawaiian Speedway.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-09-2018 , 12:29 PM
Diablo - Do yourself a favor and pick up som BA VaS. Great beer and good value at $16/4.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-09-2018 , 03:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by spidercrab
A few more that I had in the last week or so.



2011 3F Golden Blend. There are so many different versions of 3F geuze floating around that it's hard to keep track. From what I know, there are at least:

- Regular geuze
- Vintage geuze, which I believe is the brewer hand-picking the best barrels from a particular vintage and setting those aside to bottle separately
- Golden Blend, which includes 4-year old lambic, where traditional geuzes just blend 1-year, 2-year, and 3-year lambics
- Cuvee Armand & Gaston (A&G), which is made up of solely of lambic brewed at 3F. (About 10 years ago, there was some kind of thermostat malfunction that ruined all their already-brewed beer and maybe some of their equipment(?), so that for a number of years 3F was simply blending lambic brewed by others. But a few years ago, they started brewing again with new equipment, and the first A&G batch was the first 3F geuze featuring nothing but 3F-blended lambic.)

I've never had any vintage bottles, but I've had many bottles of the other 3 varieties. Because I've never tried to do side-by-sides, I don't have any good basis for comparing them. That being said, I feel like I've liked the A&G bottles I've had a lot, while some of the regular bottles I've opened recently have been mediocre. The 2011 Golden Blends that I've had have generally been great, but this one was a little bit of a let down. Perfectly carbonated, but I wasn't as wowed by it as I have been in the past. I don't know if that's a matter of time passing or bottle variation. Hopefully bottle variation, since I've got a few more sitting around. The A&G bottles cost about twice as much as (similarly-dated) regular geuze, so it's clearly in my interest to do a blind side-by-side to figure out if the premium is worth it.
The blends (e.g. A&G) vary from batch to batch intra-year as well: ***warning*** dangerous and expensive rabbit hole! I recommend never clicking on lambic.info. Lots of info here and an active FB group as well: http://www.lambic.info/Brouwerij_3_Fonteinen#Beers
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-09-2018 , 03:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by downtown
The blends (e.g. A&G) vary from batch to batch intra-year as well: ***warning*** dangerous and expensive rabbit hole! I recommend never clicking on lambic.info. Lots of info here and an active FB group as well: http://www.lambic.info/Brouwerij_3_Fonteinen#Beers
Of course I've clicked on it - I'm drinking out of a lambic.info glass in that picture!
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-09-2018 , 03:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by spidercrab
Of course I've clicked on it - I'm drinking out of a lambic.info glass in that picture!
More of a forum fyi, but cool glass! I like it.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-15-2018 , 12:01 AM
Beer peeps,



Nice hoppiness, nice peachy mango tropical flavors, but just OK. A little too much mango flavor throws it a little out of balance. $11/6-pack.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-15-2018 , 07:35 PM
El D (or others),

Recently noticed that Sierra sixers are down to $7.99 here in KY. Same price in CA?

Craft hasn't had to compete on price basically ever, but with more nationals and regionals seeing slumping, flat, or negative growth, it's coming. It's honestly hard for me to look at a six pack of something standard like an IPA from a local listed at $10.99, and then look over at Celebration or Hazy Little Thing or Torpedo and go with the local.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-16-2018 , 02:37 AM
Rdh,

7.99-8.99 yeah. And that’s also what 21A and some other CA beers cost. I just reviewed HLT and wasn’t that impressed, but celebration is great!
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-16-2018 , 05:23 PM
It's been a good week for beer drinking in my hood.

But this was probably the highlight:



2017 Atrial Rubitice latest batch
2016 Cantillon Kriek


Both rate pretty close to perfect 5s in my book. The Cantillon is certainly the best Kriek I've ever had and probably a 5/5 and I think Atrial is probably the best fruity sour made in the US and a near 5 also. Getting both at the brewery in the same afternoon was a treat.

Other highlights:

2014 Bourbon County Coffee Stout: 4/5, I think it had lost some coffee in the aging
2017 Bourbon Country Barleywine: 4.25/5, not a huge barleywine fan but this was good ****

And tonight:



Isn't the easiest getting Treehouse down in Austin. Have had Julius once and loved it, never had Alter Ego, pretty pumped!
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-18-2018 , 11:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by RunDownHouse.
El D (or others),

Recently noticed that Sierra sixers are down to $7.99 here in KY. Same price in CA?

Craft hasn't had to compete on price basically ever, but with more nationals and regionals seeing slumping, flat, or negative growth, it's coming. It's honestly hard for me to look at a six pack of something standard like an IPA from a local listed at $10.99, and then look over at Celebration or Hazy Little Thing or Torpedo and go with the local.
I'd argue this the other way. It's hard not to pick the local. Of course, a lot of the locals that make the more NEIPA styles are charging closer to $14-16/4pack. I guess that's not entirely price gouging but that style is supposed to be more expensive.

But, while I'd still rate beers like Narwhal among the very best in their style I don't think the Sierra Nevada hops really pass the bar. If I'm gonna get national distro California hops it'll be Born Yesterday when it's out or the Alpine stuff. Maybe some Stone stuff, but even that less now. The trouble with buying cross country hops is a lot of them sit on shelves so if it's not a seasonal release like Born Yesterday then you really don't know how long it's been there. It could easily be 4 months, especially since a lot of the big time producers don't always put born on dates on them.

Speedway is really good, but it's price point is ****ing crazy. I'm not even sure I like it more than fresh Breakfast Stout. Fresh Breakfast Stout is also so damn cheap and not that alcoholic. You can't really drink Speedway on a weekday, I can have a Founders Breakfast Stout on a Tuesday and it's not a deal. I also think I'll take Imperial Biscotti Break over Speedway.

I did get a bottle of Rye Barrel-aged Vietnamese Speedway Stout recently in a trade. Looking forward to trying that one, maybe tomorrow or Saturday. I've only had non-barrel aged VSS once or twice, but really liked it. Way better than the other vintages imo.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-20-2018 , 12:43 AM
Question: do you guys think ginger beer is beer? It has appeared on my lists, so have bought it, but I feel it's more like cider. And that's not among my favorites.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-20-2018 , 02:08 PM
There are two very distinct drinks: alcoholic ginger beer (which is, I think, actually brewed) and non-alcoholic ginger beer, which is basically a soft drink like lemonade or cola or whatever. I think ginger ale is also in the latter category.

I wouldn't classify even the alcoholic stuff as beer. It shares a name but it's not brewed in the same way if at all. Traditional ginger beer is actually pretty interesting: read here.

But it's definitely not cider. That very much requires apples (even in the American sense that calls apple juice cider and cider hard cider).
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-20-2018 , 08:57 PM
I'm also all ready for football tomorrow with Treehouse

I'll say, after drinking a decent amount over the past couple weeks, after drinking Trillium mostly - Treehouse is a clear cut above. I was wrong about that.

The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-20-2018 , 11:11 PM
told ya so (though I hate doppelganger).

I really don't think Trill IPAs are anything special in today's absurd environment. They're very good but plenty of local options on par. Lamplighter and Mystic come to mind. Medusa Brewing is doing some limited canning and I picked up a 4 pack of their Hidden City (el dorado IPA). It's very, very good.

That being said I almost went to Trill today to pick up some PM Dawn and Pot & Kettle.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-21-2018 , 12:39 AM
thunder, thanks, nice read!

Back to the beer niche

With a pace of three or more non-alcoholic beers per day (good stuff!), having 30-40 to choose from, some expertise is inevitable, I guess.

Last edited by plaaynde; 01-21-2018 at 12:48 AM.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-21-2018 , 12:17 PM
I think something about Trill IPAs is particularly fatiguing after a while. I do think they are noticeably better than almost any shelf beer, but they all tste like the same generic “Trillium” beer to me now, dry and slightly acidic. I also feel like the fairly consistent malt bill and religious use of CTZ doesn’t allow for different hops to be showcased as truly different beers. Even Headroom this summer was just like Trill beer with extra galaxy on top.

TH is not only better on an individual beer basis but the difference between Sap and Julius and Green and Bright feels much larger than between any two Trill IPAs. My tastes are probably just changing though.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-21-2018 , 07:28 PM
Sour fans,

Had any of these?

The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-22-2018 , 03:42 AM
Just got back from Denver and had both of the epic ones. (Assuming the 2nd to last on the right is the pineapple I had).

I liked them both. Nothing outstanding, but definitely worth a taste. They had a Syrah one in the taproom that was the crowd favorite. If you see that one I’d def grab it.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-23-2018 , 04:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake7777
I think something about Trill IPAs is particularly fatiguing after a while. I do think they are noticeably better than almost any shelf beer, but they all tste like the same generic “Trillium” beer to me now, dry and slightly acidic. I also feel like the fairly consistent malt bill and religious use of CTZ doesn’t allow for different hops to be showcased as truly different beers. Even Headroom this summer was just like Trill beer with extra galaxy on top.

TH is not only better on an individual beer basis but the difference between Sap and Julius and Green and Bright feels much larger than between any two Trill IPAs. My tastes are probably just changing though.
I agree with this analysis. Trillium IPA are boring and have little going for them other than availability. TH still feels like a treat
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-25-2018 , 12:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by boscoboy
I agree with this analysis. Trillium IPA are boring and have little going for them other than availability. TH still feels like a treat
Trillium is still an elite IPA brewery. I give a slight nod to Treehouse but I also don't get it nearly as much. But DDH Congress St is as good a beer as any out there. I also love Citra Cutting Tiles and plenty of others.

Had my first Hidden Valley the other night and was completely blown away. Described as a sour DIPA and it certainly ticked both boxes for me. Starts off almost cotton candy like and fades into a nice full body DIPA
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-25-2018 , 01:27 AM
Do you mean Hudson Valley?

I’ve had their sour DIPAs are a little much for me. Just super sweet with all the lactose and vanilla. Definitely appreciate the style and technique but it’s something I’d split a can of for dessert probably.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-25-2018 , 11:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mullen
Do you mean Hudson Valley?

I’ve had their sour DIPAs are a little much for me. Just super sweet with all the lactose and vanilla. Definitely appreciate the style and technique but it’s something I’d split a can of for dessert probably.
Yes, Hudson Valley. That's what posting from bed gets you. I've only had the one can, Graven Image, but it was really good and certainly unique in an IPA world where every seems to be trying to do the same crazy things, it stood out for me. Not saying I'd want to drink them all night, but as a last beer of the night it was very impressive. I'm sure the novelty wears off but the one I had was memorable and I'd like to try more.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-26-2018 , 05:12 PM
Had this on tap not long ago and enjoyed it (link below). I rate the malty taste about medium - I don't care much for heavy malted beer. This seemed to have a good balance with some hoppy flavor coming through. Any other winter ales out in the forest that are worth more than a sip or two?


elysian-bifrost-winter-ale
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-26-2018 , 05:20 PM
Zeno,

I feel similarly about heavy malted beer, but I think this winter ale is pretty tasty: https://www.anchorbrewing.com/mobile/beer/christmas_ale

You might still be able to find some on the shelves.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote
01-27-2018 , 02:40 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by thunderbolts
Much as I dislike BrewDog, if they distro to where you are their Nanny State is by far the best low alcohol (0.5%) beer I've encountered.

Cobra Zero is hands-down the worst. Tasted like aluminium water rather than lager.
BrewDog Nanny State 0.5%



The aroma is really intriguing, citrus and mango. You want hops? You've got it! Special beer, maybe not very much taste immediately, but it comes forward in the aftertaste, a feeling of subtleness yet to be discovered.
The Beer connoisseur thread Quote

      
m