Quote:
Originally Posted by Doc89
My pet peeve is the exact opposite of this; people who make ridiculous claims and then are completely unwilling to back them up with money. Why should we sit here for hours, pointlessly theorycrafting when we can have a situation set up which both of you believe will be profitable in the long run?
If someone says to me, "I think I will win in situation X 50% of the time", and I say to them "Ok, lets play situation X and I will lay you +150", and they say, "Nah bro why you gotta get all alpha male and bring money into this?", that says to me they don't actually believe what they claim to believe.
Could you accomplish the same goal offering to just play the matches out as a friendly exercise of finding out the best way? You know... for the sake of finding out the answer to the betterment of all parties involved rather than BET MONEY DUDE.
Why do we all need to pound our chests and throw MONEY on the line!? I mean, a lot of people, esp in non poker forums, can't afford to prop bet, even a small amount. That doesn't make them wrong. Even if one could afford it, it's sort of a silly outcome. Why do we need to bet money? Does that make you feel better when you challenge my ideas?
This has become a bigger and bigger problem imo. On the politard forum a couple months ago, I was arguing an idea. Unlike SC2, it wasn't testable in even a remotely accurate form and was something rather arbitrary. Yet one guy challenged me to bet 5,000 dollars on the idea as judged by a random group of people on something entirely arbitrary. When I declined, he responded to my posts 3-4 times goading me into betting with him. When I would not bet that, he declared I was wrong.
I mean, really?
The same thing happened to Henry17 in OOT a couple months ago. IT was really silly, but after he declined to prop several thousand on something, we had multiple guys pounding their chest like a gorilla declaring themselves winners of the debate. IT's not like he or I couldn't afford the challenged props. It's just that it's a silly way to settle things.