Yeah I hear you guys loud and clear, I know how this looks from the outside in. But I genuinely think I was(/am?) happier in this relationship than I would be being single. I mean its hard to judge because last time I was single I was a lot younger and (yes not old enough to drink, 18 in New Zealand) so maybe there's some bias derived from that. It's also possible that my subconscious is too scared too break up with her and I'm just telling my self I'm happier like this to avoid having to do the dirty work.
But when I think about it like I actually was really happy being in a relationship with her.. she was like real chill with me going clubbing and **** most weekends, let me go to strip clubs lol, had full freedom really, I was doing everything I did when I was single anyway apart from trying to hook up with chicks. The only difference is I had a cool girl I was talking to more or less 'waiting' for me and I had an excuse to go to Brazil in my holidays which was even better. Think I may have gave the wrong impression itt that I was cucked or something but na we actually had a really good set up.
Basically my new plan is to not talk to her until either she hits me up, or its been one week, whatever comes first. I'll simply apologize, say what I have to say while giving off a vibe of indifference, and treat it as a free roll..
if she wants to forgive me and give it another shot then great we'll try make it work again and if it doesn't feel the same after a while or it's weird/just not working we'll break up. If she doesn't even want to try then that's fine too, I'll just be single. The EV between both options are gonna run fairly close anyway imo.
big ty to everyone that posted and is posting here proper helped me a lot,
will update as we progress