Quote:
Originally Posted by Poker Rep.
When will you be in town to give the BB ante a try?!
I'll be in town next week, but I'm not sure I'm going to make it to the Wynn this trip. I will be back for 1 month+ over the summer, and I'm sure I'll play some Wynn events at that time and likely some BB ante event somewhere, just so I can say I have tried it.
As it stands my objections to the format are theoretical. However, unless I'm missing some important point (not out of the realm of possibility), I don't know that experiencing it is going to change my mind. The only thing that would change my mind is some clear empirical evidence of a significant benefit which will overcome the drawbacks. And to reiterate some other posts, my main complaint at this time is the format makes the "luck of the draw" when it comes to table breaks far more consequential, since the BB is essentially 2.5x bigger than in the usual format. And, of course, this necessary (at least at this point considering the technology and methods available to do table breaks) evil will be even greater when stacks start getting shallow.
So, time savings would have to be pretty large in order to justify introducing that drawback. Unless the baseline consists of dealers who are completely incompetent, then I don't see how eliminating the collection of antes will represent a significant time savings. It just doesn't take very long to collect antes, even for less experienced dealers. Of course there will be instances where someone totally screws the process up. But those instances are far rarer than other dealing screw-ups that cost much more time. And of course, time savings related to ante collection is dwarfed by the things that are the real drivers of hand time.
So then it comes down to... is the game better when there are far fewer players with any investment in the hand and one player with a much larger investment? I'm not really prepared to answer that question, but just in theory, it doesn't seem like the answer is a clear yes.
So I guess we'll see how this all shakes out.