Quote:
Originally Posted by akashenk
The link you provided uses the word “must” and “may” in different sections, neither of which directly indicate they are applicable to poker tournaments. It does not surprise me the IRS language is vague and up for interpretation. This is why we have tax courts and why the majority of people who don’t have access to good accountants are at a distinct disadvantage.
In any case, 300x, if that is a real threshold, is not one which the vast majority of WSOP winners will reach. So I think the actual WSOP policy remains a bit of a mystery. Wouldn’t it be nice if they just posted if so it were clear to all?
Aka - You have been very helpful to readers on many issues, you have experience and are willing share that in many cases for the benefit of others.
HOWEVER you also don't know when to just say I AM WRONG or I didn't know that. You are entitled to your OPINION and typically you support that opinion with a well written argument. FINE good for you.
Tax withholding regulations are not OPINIONS, Venues don't get to pick and choose what they follow if they are following the law. Regulations change over time and what may be true 5 years ago are NOT necessarily accurate today. The WSOP policy is not a "mystery" and while CAESARS has on EXCEEDINGLY RARE occasions chosen to interpret the IRS code slightly differently (backers income reporting is a specific example in the past) the regulations for withholding are very clear and also very specific to the type of wager that generated the payout.
The Link is absolutely specific to poker and other gaming winnings as to what the current IRS Treasury regulations require. So for the benefit of those that read and pay attention to your posts please stop the obfuscation.
NOTE: To be perfectly clear I am NOT disputing Greg Raymer and his personal experience. I suspect but DO NOT KNOW that the 300X criteria became part of the regulations well after his ME victory. Greg in his prior lifetime was an attorney (patent I believe) and can read a legal document and the tax law and has enough real world experience on cashing and W2G's to be someone to pay attention to.