Quote:
Originally Posted by kioshk
I still listen to the Beatles, and I feel no need to defend their music. They're GOAT. They're the ****ing Beatles. If you don't like the Beatles, gg.
Yeah, Beatles-bashing is always just a cry for attention. You can't seriously look at the quantity of hits, and the amount of influence they generated over seven measly years, and say they're overrated. If anything, they're underrated. Being tired of them is a separate and valid point--I don't care if I never hear Hey Jude again, but that doesn't make it, or them, overrated.
The Who otoh, I will go to the mat for being overrated. They were a great pop group through the mid-sixties, and Meaty Beaty Big and Bouncy compares favorably with any collection of pop singles, but Pete Townshend crawled up his own rectum circa 1968 and never reemerged. Townshend is a great songwriter, and an underrated guitar player imo, but I think he was just too clever for his own good. There's something precious and self-conscious about stuff like Tommy and a lot of Townshend's material suffers from this habitual need to narrate from some self-appointed "genius critic of a generation" position. His songs insist upon themselves, I guess I'm saying.
Also, Keith Moon, despite being a great showman and one of rock's great personalities, couldn't play his way out of one of John Bonham's socks. And Daltrey sings like the sheet metal worker he was.
Entwistle GOAT tho, or at least the bassline to Won't Get Fooled Again is.