Quote:
Originally Posted by Markusgc
Can you post or PM the recipe which suggests a secondary fermentation so I can see it?
The less you expose your beer to potential contaminants the lower the chance of infection. Opening up your carboy another time just increases the risk imo.
Brewer's Best IPA
This is a similar recipe from the same manufacturer, I'll be doing this one tomorrow anyway but the one in my Carboy now was a PSA IPA. But on page 2 along the right side under two-stage (secondary) fermentation, it talks about how they recommends you employ this process.
I was always told exactly what youre saying, the less you open your Carboy the better.
Quote:
Originally Posted by RunDownHouse
Most of the recipes I've seen that call for a secondary are either to add another ingredient - dry hop, fruit, spices, etc - or are bigger beers that benefit from bulk aging. For aging, the main reason to age in secondary as opposed to primary is to avoid yeast autolysis, which is basically the yeast eating itself and then rupturing, releasing all sorts of nasty off-flavors into your beer. Do a bit of digging on homebrew forums and you'll find that there's a bit of a debate about whether autolysis is ever actually a danger for homebrewers.
Personally, I don't sweat leaving beers in primary for a month or more if needed. I think I would start thinking about it at the 6- or 8-week mark, but I've never had to worry about it. In general, Mark is right on: the less you move your beer, the better. As for the act itself, yes, you just siphon into another carboy, being careful to leave your trub behind.
This is interesting and probably something that I need to read up on a bit, thanks for your input.
The recipe I attached calls for 7-10 days in the primary, is there any advantage/disadvantage to leaving it in the primary for longer. Im sure that it is recipe/style specific, for example my last recipe was a Belgian triple and I left it for 5 weeks.