Civil War, Alex Garland, 2024
This is a well-made, shocking, almost-too-real tale of a group of photo journalists trying to get to Washington DC to interview the (Trump-like ) President of a never-named, apparently fascistic government that's about to be overrun by rebel forces of the "Western Front" alliance.
We are never told what the politics of either side actually are, or how a 2nd American civil war came to pass, as the story is mostly told through the eyes of the journalists: Kirstin Dunst, Wagner Moura (Narcos), Callee Spaeny (Priscilla), and Stephen McKinley Henderson (Dune). Jesse Plemons and Nick Offerman (as the President) have cameos. Offerman, Spaeny and Henderson also starred in Garland's much under-appreciated limited series, Devs...and there are some other actors from that great show in Civil War.
It's basically a road trip, with our journalists at turns evading or documenting battles and various atrocities.
Never seen Dunst so dirty and dour before, but she does a great job as the world-weary veteran war photo-journalist who takes Spaeny's character under her wing. As I still think of her as the cute girl from Bring It On, it's strange seeing her play an adult woman. (I mean, she's about to turn 42, so that's on me not her lol)
I have two opinions about this movie...the first is that it is incredibly well-shot, good script, with a propulsive narrative. Very good performances, realistic "you-are-in-the middle-of-it" battle scenes, and a third act that is astonishingly scary as we are basically witnessing a siege on our nation's capitol.
This is a masterfully made film. Garland is on top of his game here. The music is discordant and contradictory, often with happy songs or ballads over disturbing scenes, that confuses and rattles the viewer even more than the images.
My 2nd opinion is, I hated watching this. Don't get me wrong, it's a very good movie, but like last year's The Zone Of Interest, it's so realistically horrific (though with a splash of Hollywood melodrama) that I don't think I'd ever want to watch it again.
I'm not some gung-ho "America, love it or leave it", big-time patriot, you know? But I hated watching Americans fighting Americans and commit atrocities. There's a scene with Jesse Plemons (real-life husband of Dunst) -- who is some sort of paramilitary psychopath our journalists stumble across while he and his compatriots are dumping bodies into a pit and covering them with lime -- that was so horrific (there's that word again) that I found myself holding my breath through the whole thing. This is not "fun" movie-going, or a choreographed ballet of violence like in a John Wick movie - violence we know to be fake and impressive and exhilarating. No, this scene was not that. It actually reminded me of a scene in the Dennis Quaid/Stellan Skarsgaard movie about the Bosnian War, Savior, where we see a busload of fleeing, unarmed Muslims stopped by Serb soldiers, marched off the bus and executed in a brutal, horrifyling manner.
I read that Plemons, who is uncredited, played the part with only a couple of days of prep because the original actor had dropped out. He's probably one of our finest actors by this point, and he has a sociopathic charm that is so real, so horrifying, that when I watched the scene, I was not watching a movie - it seemed real. And I felt almost as scared and helpless as his victims.
Just brutal.
Another reason why I hated watching this movie was the third act - which is the siege on Washington - as we see full-on battle scenes as the Western Forces overrun the military, and later, secret service members.
You know how it's fun to see the White House blow up in Independence Day?
Well, I wasn't having fun with this movie. Watching soldiers launching rockets at the Lincoln Memorial, crumbling one corner of it, seeing helicopters and war planes screaming over the city while anti-aircraft guns fire into the sky with tracers, looking like footage from Ukraine...no, that wasn't fun, either. In fact, it surprised me how emotional it made me. An extended sequence where our journalist are following a platoon who is trying to break through the White House perimeter, with gunfire, bazookas, and tanks - again with us in the middle of it all - was chaotic and terrifying. A final stand gun battle in the halls of the White House as the soldiers try to breach the Oval Office is also terrifying.
Again, it's all incredibly realistic and well-made. But that's why I hated watching it. This wasn't Gerard Butler trying to free the President from a terrorist attack or Harrison Ford kicking Gary Oldman off his plane, you know? Somehow, it was different to me this time. Your results may vary, of course, but holy sh*t, I was shaking watching it all.
So I'm torn. Very good movie. But with how our country is right now, with divisiveness and red/blue partisanship, and on the day our former President is a defendant in a criminal trial, well...Civil War doesn't seem all that far-fetched. And I'd hate to think there are some Americans who will watch this and think, "that's what's gotta happen." Because you know they will. And that's not Garland's fault...but I'm not quite sure how responsible the movie is in the climate we as a country our in these days.
That may sound like I'm overreacting, and maybe I am, but man, this is not just an entertainment and may even be a cautionary tale. But I think I'm going to have to go see the latest King Kong/Godzilla movie to get this sour taste out of my mouth.
Last edited by Dominic; Yesterday at 10:05 PM.