Quote:
Originally Posted by riverboatking
don't feel like NCFOM n TWWB are in same genre as unforgiven.
all 3 of them are among my favs fwiw.
I don't know. I feel like all 5 movies brought something different to what is the
western genre, redefined it in its own way. After all, when people think western movies, they oftentimes picture a spaghetti western, a movie like
The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly, or other Sergio Leone movies that implemented the genre and stuck around. But
Unforgiven kills the myth of the
lonesome hero cowboy and redefines the western genre (or brings it back to its roots).
What is a western movie after all? Originally, IMO, it is the contact with a
strange land (conquering the unoccupied western lands) and
strange people (natives). So it is the interaction with
the other. I feel that
There Will be Blood depicts a fascinating unreconciliable relationship in between chasing the riches (Daniel Day Lewis) that drives an oil digger, to the conservative approach of a clergy boy, and ultimately, both of their divergent relationships to the land.
Dead Man has a unique Jim Jarmusch anti-genre feeling to it (like Jarmusch loves to do) by having the native,
the other, having studied arts in Europe (haha), the gunslinger, Johnny Depp, be a city boy that instantly becomes a sharp shooter, and in the background, the scorching rifts of Neil Young! Dead Man is, by all means, an anti-western.
Blueberry introduces something unique to the relationship with
the other, as the hero gunslinger was brought up by native people (as oppose to having them as the stereotypical enemy), and the final showdown is not done with guns, but through an ayahuasca journey.
As far as
No Country for Old Men, I love the ending and the conversation with Tommy Lee Jones and the other fellow - the name escapes me. In this movie, the relationship with the western land has been somewhat transgressed, as if stepping disrespectfully on sacred ground... The old get older, times are changing, and the land has lost its sacredness.
Anyhow, hope this all makes sense, and that my understanding of western movies is not spewy...
Last edited by Dubnjoy000; 02-13-2014 at 01:18 AM.