Quote:
Originally Posted by Zeno
...
Gibson?
If it's older than 15 years, it's pretty good. They've been sitting on their laurels and it shows.
They do take care of lefties, so they are very popular with us.
Martin?
Love child of folky type. They sound okay to me, but I don't like the feel very much. They tend to have lower sustain and higher timbre than other acoustics, with the exception of Ovation.
Fender?
Not a fan of Fender at all, except for the telecaster because you can't fake talent on a telecaster.
I hate strats and never used one I liked.
Fender is another company that sat on their laurels and it shows. They somehow get worse every year.
I used to have a Fender acoustic. It was pretty okay.
Epiphone?
Put them in the "most improved" category. They are finally making decent sounding guitars, but anyone who buys one may want to swap the pickups. I'm not a fan of their fretboards and the stock pickups aren't responsive enough for me.
(Washburn has very hot / responsive pickups, which can be jarring if you aren't used to that)
Seagull?
Never used or seen one, honestly. Do they make lefties?
Gretsch?
You can love them or hate them. I'm not a fan of the plastic fretboards they use, but in the right hands, they are amazing.
The Rev uses a Gretsch, so it's the prime guitar for the rockabilly genre.
Taylor?
Eh....
Rickenbacker?
They are more known for their basses. I've never used their guitars.
Ibanez?
Sigh... they are way too spread out in my opinion. Their cheaper guitars feel like they are priced 2x what they should be. Basically unplayable unless you want to spend $1,000 or more.
My last acoustic was an Ibanez and it was amazing, with a deep timbre, good sustain, and super expressive, It's a total bummer I couldn't ever get it fixed.
Instruments are such a personal thing. I'd buy any of the above brands if the guitar I happen to test out feels right to me. That's a quasi-concept really. Variations between wood, age, pickups, and so on can make the same model sound very different from its twin. Plus stupid things like strings (their age and type), humidity the day you test it, how much ear wax you have, and so on can make a major difference in your impression that day.
My last guitar was a cheap tele clone and I was fine playing it. They say the tone is in the hands and that's pretty true in my opinion. I'd never judge someone for the guitar they play.... well, don't play metal on a tele, haha.