Mmmmm, Chicago deep dish Pizza. A deep pool of luscious goodness! Fresh sweet tomatoes, various toppings, cheese and a tender biscuit like crust. Uno’s, Lou Malnati’s, Giordano’s; the names invoke wistful expressions at their very mention. Chicago deep dish is different that what most people think of when you say deep dish. Deep dish does not equal thick crust. Thicker than New York Style and less chewy, yet not the thick bready “Sicilian Style”.

Pans
The pan is a critical element of Chicago style pizza. You need a pan that allows the center of the pie to cook through, while at the same time allowing the crust on the sides and bottom to brown and finish before the top scorches and burns. To this end I prefer the 2-inch deep tin coated steel pans made by American Metal Crafters. These pans are available at most restaurant supply stores or over the Internet. I’ve found that aluminum pans - both plain and black anodized tend to cook the side and bottom too slowly. Don’t despair if you already have an aluminum pizza pan, you can cover the top of the pie with aluminum foil once it reaches its desired doneness to prevent it from burning while you wait for the sides and bottom to get done. If you don’t want to purchase a specific pan to try a pizza, a well seasoned cast iron skillet will work, but you’ll want to lower the oven heat and watch the pie carefully to insure the crust doesn’t burn.

There are two pan styles generally available; straight side and tapered side. While tapered pans allow easier removal of the pie, straight sided pans are more authentic.

If purchasing steel pans you’ll want to season and treat them in the same manner as a cast iron skillet.

There are two pan styles generally available; straight side and tapered side. While tapered pans allow easier removal of the pie, straight sided pans are more authentic and cook a little more evenly.

Examples

Aluminum pan with tapered sides.



Steel Pans






The two steel pans shown are a 7 inch and a 14 inch. The 7 inch will easily feed 2 people and the 14 will feed 6-8. A 10 inch is a nice compromise in that it will feed a group and not be too difficult to remove from the pan.

The Crust
Chicago style pizza crust is a firm bready crust with a biscuit like texture. While no major Chicago pizzerias use cornmeal in their dough, it’s easier to get the proper texture at home by incorporating it into the dough. Plus, I just like the additional taste.

Dough Ingredients




If you want that authentic yellow tint to the dough so famous in Chicago, add 4 or 5 drops of yellow food coloring to the water before adding (yep, that's right, it's just food coloring)


In a mixing bowl, add the water, sugar, yeast, flour, cornmeal, and salt.


Mix on low speed for a couple of minutes until dough comes together.


Once the dough starts to come together, slowly add the oil.


Mix on medium speed for 6 additional minutes.

The dough should be somewhat wet and smooth, but not sticky. The dough should weigh about 916 grams (for a 14 inch pie).


Form the dough into a ball and place in a bowl. Loosely and completely cover with plastic wrap and then a dish towel and put the refrigerator for an overnight rise.


The next day

Pre heat your oven to 450 degrees (non convection mode) at least 30 minutes prior to baking.

Take the dough out of the refrigerator about one hour prior to making the pizza - you want it to be somewhat cool and firm so it will hold it's shape in the pan.


Coat the bottom of a well seasoned deep dish pan with butter flavored shortening.


Don't skimp on the shortening




We want a dough thickness of about 3/16's to 1/4 inch across the entire pan.


One way of testing that is to take a Sharpie and mark a chef's knife at the proper level...


then gently insert the knife tip into the dough to test the thickness.


Place the dough ball in the center of the pan and press it out until it covers the entire bottom.




You want to use your fingers to form a lip as you go, this will be pulled up to form the sides.






The edge should be pinched up against the side of the pan.



If the dough resists holding it's shape, cover with a towel and let rest for 15 to 20 minutes before trying again. A little dough over the top of the pan is a good thing as there will be a little shrinkage.


Finished dough


you can see that the over pinched dough has shrunk back down to the correct level


The fixin's


Cheese
Slice down some part skim mozzarella about a 1/4 inch or so per slice. Whole milk mozzarella has too much moisture and will release a lot of liquid during cooking making the crust soggy and the sauce runny.


Layer the cheese in the bottom of the pan covering as much of the surface of the dough as possible.


The sliced cheese acts as a moisture barrier and allows the bottom of the pie to cook correctly. Shredded cheese should not be used.


At this point you can add your favorite topping, in this example we are adding home made Italian sausage and pepperoni.

Pepperoni


Sausage - most Chicago pizzerias add raw sausage since the sausage will have plenty of time to fully cook in the oven. If you want to brown it first, feel free.


Time to sauce


The sauce
Canned crushed tomatoes and a touch of sweet basil. That's it. The best canned tomatoes that I've found are the 6-in-1 brand, they have the sweetness lacking in most canned tomatoes and don't have a lot of surplus water. If they are not available locally they can be ordered off the internet (see the source list). Believe me, they're worth it. I've found that most other brands need to be strained in order to remove some of the water before using.


Sauce the pizza and use the ladle to work the sauce down into the toppings




Leave a little room at the top (about a 1/2 inch) of the pie to allow for the bottom dough to rise so that your sauce doesn't overflow.


Sprinkle some sweet basil on the top of the sauce when finished. (If you are wondering about the lone pepperoni on top - this pizza was only half sausage - the pepperoni indicated the sausage half.)


Use your ladle to work the basil into the sauce a little so that it won't burn


Place in the center on the bottom rack of the oven and cook for 25 to 30 minutes, turning once half way through. Use a spatula to slightly push the edge of the pie away from the pan to check for doneness.


Remove from the oven and let cool for about 3 minutes.




[size=18]Removal[/size]
Getting these pies out of the pan in one piece requires a little practice. For larger pies 12 inches and up it's difficult to the the pie out in one piece. For large pies, cutting it in the pan is usually the best bet. A fish spatula is an excellent tool for this.


With a little practice it is possible to remove even the large pies from the pan in one piece.


In order to get the pie out in one piece you will need two tools, a pizza pan grabber and a flexible cake spatula.


Grab the pan with the grabber.


Work the cake spatula around the sides of the pie to loosen it.


Tilt the pan slightly and work the spatula in at an angle; you then want to push the spatula under the pie (this will cause the pie to lift slightly)






Once the spatula has slipped under the bottom of the pie


Quickly lift it out.


You want to do all the above in one motion, it's sort of a grip; tilt; slip/lift; flip motion.

If you are doing a larger pie you might want to have 2 larger spatulas handy (grill spatulas work well here). Insert the cake spatula on one side and lift the pie, then insert one of the grill spatulas. Repeat on the other side and use the grill spatulas to lift the pizza out. With a little practice you can use one grill spatula, and tilt the pan quickly, sort of flopping the pie out in one motion.

These pizza freeze really well, and will keep in the freezer up to 6 months with little loss of quality. Tip: a 7 inch pie fits perfectly in a 1 gallon food saver bag. If your are going to vacuum pack your pizzas, make sure they are fully cooled (I like to refrigerate them over night) and use a Foodsaver with the insta-seal option to avoid crushing the pie.

Enjoy!

Wow, A+. As a native Chicagoan living in Kentucky, I've always wanted to make my own deep dish pies, but I always seem to end up springing the $60 and ordering some frozen Lou's. I'll have to try this one weekend, thanks for taking the time. Finished product looks amazing.

oh ****.... you did not just do this.... my god so awesome! Thanks!

Really excellent job!

Those Escalon tomatoes are only $2.75 per can which includes shipping if you buy 6 cans or more from their site. It's a great deal, but when I ordered in the past I did have several dented cans from shipping damage.

Fantastic work.

I am so happy you posted this after loving the pizza I had in Chicago in late September.

Now, how does a novice such as myself convert your ingredient table? Or do you actually use the scale?

Good post, I will try this. I grew up on Malnati's pizza and sometimes order the frozen stuff. Next time I get in the mood for it I will try this recipe. I have experimented a little, but have never made a deep dish pizza I particularly like. BTW, Lou Malnati hated pepperoni and I am not sure they even had it in the restaurant when he was alive. I could be wrong on them allowing it, but I know Lou did not like pepperoni and we never had one of his pizzas with it. His sausage was and is so good though.

I can't srticulate why, but I never liked pepperoni on deep dish pizza, even though I like it on thin crust. I grew up on Giordanos, and I prefer it slightly over Malnotti's. I've never had Uno. My family gets Giordanos about once a month. When was a kid, I would always make sure to save a couple pieces and put them in the fridge cuz I think it tastes better cold the next day.

BTW, if you go to Giordanos, don't ever get anything other than pizza, everything else is nasty.

very cool. i made pizzas at lou malnati's (not all the beginning steps) during jr. high a few times for this fundraising type thing and remember it being quite similar except the tomatoes were a lot more solid, as we see when we go there and regularly have huge chunks on our slices.

Holy cow. What a TR. Thank you.

Great walkthrough. I've never had pizza like this, or even really seen it. Is it common in any other areas besides Chicago?

Is it standard to have all the cheese below the sauce like that?

wow great work

Amazing...

Nope, it's pretty exclusive to Chicago. There are chain places across the country (Old Chicago Pizza is one, there might be some Uno's locations outside IL/IN/WI) that can serve a decent impersonation of deep dish, but if you really have a jones for a deep-dish and can't go to Chicago proper you might want to look into ordering a frozen pie, Bacino's and Lou Malnati's will ship them, albeit at a pretty steep price.

How you see it is how it is. In order from the top sauce > tops > chee

Wow. Great job. Incredibly detailed.

Oh god. I am going to do this asap.

OP - as another northern virginia resident (alexandria), you can appreciate the TOTAL lack of good pizza in this area.

Please tell me you have leftovers so I can come by and get some. I'm in total withdrawal.

Here's my personal ranking for deep dish in chicago:

1. Arenellos - a completely unknown hole in the wall store in the south suburbs. It's takeout only, and in a fairly ghetto neighborhood, right next to a liquor store. No other place comes even remotely close in my opinion. In fact, it's so much better than the other chains, that I'd almost argue that I actually prefer thin crust pizza if I can't get it from here.

2. Giardanos - good texture, but the sauce isn't as sweet as I like. Sausage is quite good.

3. Lou Malnatis - I just am not a big fan of their crust (or even butter crust). Good flavor, though.

Unos/Eduardos/other I don't really consider to be very "chicago" style.

OP - what did you use for sausage in your recipe?

Kind of interesting considering Uno was the first deep-dish restaurant?

Gone too corporate lately, though. AFAIK it's now called "Uno's Chicago Grill." Ridiculous.

Home made Italian style sausage.

Ya, I realize it's the original - it's just a slightly different style I guess that I don't like as much.

This is great, the best deep dish place here just went out of biz about 3 months ago
(pepperoni deep dish was better than anywhere in chicago, but the sausage sucked), and the only decent place is 30$/pie. again ty op

Nice work, OP. I'm going to Chicago for the first time in June. Any other native's have suggestions on the best pizza places?

doubt it, man. dno where you're from or whatever, but meh. specifically the pan pizza at pequods, with pepperoni and jalapeno. definitely my current favorite pizza. fairly sure they make their own pepperoni, which has a nice bit of kick to it. pequods isn't "deep dish" in that it is not arranged in the order shown in op, but rather a "pan" pizza, as is unos.

i'm fairly sure there's been extensive discussion of this, if not in the Chicago thread in this forum, elsewhere in EDGF and OOT.

to me,
pequods (ref'd above and with burned cheese on the edge of the crust) > malnattis (both the "lou's special" and veggie pizza are great) > other

other:

giordanos - definitely have to get a spinach pie, sort of a uniquely chicago thing. pizza is nearly identical to above but with spinach instead of meat.

ginos - i personally don't like because they do a corn meal crust, others think the corn meal crust is the best thing ever

eduardos - very similar to giordanos, i haven't eaten at either in a while, so i couldn't really give a good reason to go to one over the other except proximity

that's the majority of the more popular deep dish places... there's of course more. there's also been a boom in thin crust pizza in the last year or so, with everyone and their mom opening a wood fire oven place. meh?

See my previous post. My best advice is to order a sausage pizza - that's what really makes these. Pepperoni tastes the same everywhere.

Giordanos and Lou Malnantis are at about the same level. Both pretty good. If you go Lou Malnati you have to get the butter crust. Without it the pizza tastes very bland.

I'd pass on Ginos / Unos / Eduardos. I'm told Dewey's is good, but have never eaten there.

The absolute best is Arenello's, but if you're in Chicago it's nowhere near where you'd want to go (about a 30minute drive to the south suburbs in a somewhat sketchy area and takeout only ). However, it still might be worth it.

I'm investigating the Pequods place the above poster just mentioned.

If you want thin crust, check out Aurelios.

Man, this brings back memories of college at the University of Illinois in the late 80s, where this downstate Illinois (near St. Louis) kid was first exposed to Chicago deep dish pizza and Chicago style hot dogs.