Quote:
Finished The Road. It was the most immediately moving piece of fiction I've read in a long time. Aesthetically, for McCarthy, nothing special at all, which is fine.
I did find it powerful, but problematically so. I've got a 4 year old boy, and as a parent I find stuff that plays on that parent child relationship is incredibly potent. But it's also incredibly easy to do so. I regard it as effectively a cheap and often slightly manipulative way to get a strong emotional reaction from the reader/viewer when a tv show or a film or a book places a parent-child relationship under pressure, or places them in tragic situations. The Road was that for me. I worry enough as it is about bringing a child into a world which is only a couple of generations from trucking huge numbers of people into death camps as it is, The Road didn't teach me anything, it only caused me pain.
I also thought it featured quite a lot of lazy apocalypse genre tropes.
That said, the quality of the prose did make me realise how much allowances for junky writing one often has to make when reading a lot of SF.