Quote:
Originally Posted by Blarg
In his day, having long hair or listening to rock and roll were called deviant behaviors, and among a sizeable amount of people not going to church was thought of as one, so you can hardly blame him.
Heh, this is a very good point. Just surprised me that he seemed very socially/psychologically aware in some areas, but not others.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Landonfan
Just finished Dune. Great book, but sort of tilting that, outside of space travel and a few other neat-o inventions, humanity doesn't really seem to have progressed that much in 8k years. Just seems weird that there's a caste system and everyone's knife fighting that far into the future.
I'll still def be reading the rest of the series, though.
I never really got into Dune, though not from lack of trying. While I think it's pretty well written, I just can't take the setting:
I think attempts to do things like feudal empires in space are both unrealistic and a little bit silly. Existing off a planet is immensely different from being confined to a single world. Vastly greater difficulties in communication, transport, trade and the rest of it (and higher living costs/requirements) are going to produce an automatically decentralizing effect (barring some miracle faster-than-light discovery). Self-sufficiency within any kind of space habitat is immeasurably more important than it is for a single nation on Earth and the hold of any corporation/state is going to be infinitely more tenuous because of it if the habitat/planet doesn't
need their assistance. Trying to put political systems that evolved on our effectively 2-dimensional world (ie flat land and borders) into 3d space irks me. Any future space technology is going to move people into looser social structures, not back in time to feudalism
Then again, I'm probably going to be doing my dissertation on something like this, so maybe I'm biased.
Oh, yeah, and the knives thing is almost as bad as lightsabers