I just finished watching the finale,
better Nate than lever! I was a fan of the original BSG when I was a wee lad and watched the mini-series, but then got behind when the series started and never got back to it until now for various reasons. Put me in the camp that was very satisfied with how it wrapped up. I get most of the criticism, but to me it stayed true to the characters and themes, and the unanswered questions are mostly best left unresolved. A+ show.
BTW, the entire series is streaming on Prime.