Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread

06-12-2018 , 10:10 AM
Why are you limiting the possibility of also offering a baseline wage?
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 10:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bahbahmickey
lol. You are so sure that you are right that you can't give one scenario that you are right.

So if me and my neighbor are stuck on an island catching 40 fish a month and then my neighbor creates a net that catches many times that I am somehow worse off? I'm sure he wouldn't pay me x fish to build him a home, start him a fire, build him a boat or any other action where he'd be better off because he doesn't like me and he wants all the fish/widgets to himself. Yeah, cool story.
We were talking about income inequality ... distributional effects. You can make up all kinds of "stories" in your head where you create a bunch more wealth in the economy to justify the increase in earnings for a person. But if you want to think about distributional effects you need to hold the wealth of the economy constant. Otherwise you have too many moving parts and it obfuscates what you're trying to think about. It is literally impossible for me to make this any clearer so I won't try again.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 10:59 AM
This thread isn't fun anymore.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 11:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bahbahmickey
If you like the idea of sharing profits in hamburger sales with employees you should open up a burger joint and TRY to hire people by telling them they can share in profits and the risks. That option is available to you as it is to mcdonalds who has taken a lot of risks to get where they are today.

It doesn't even have to be burgers. Go start any company and try to hire people by telling them they are commission only. Some may like it, but a lot of people want the consistent paycheck that comes with other companies. Of course, it is easy to sit on the sidelines and say "Now that an owner of a company took all the risk and succeeded he should have to share a higher percent of her profits with those that took zero risk."
You should watch The Founder if you want to know how Ray Kroc made his money. Spoiler alert:

Spoiler:
It was by ripping off Mac and Dick McDonald
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 11:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fidstar-poker
This thread isn't fun anymore.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 11:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by allinontheturn
that's better...
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 12:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tuma
Why are you limiting the possibility of also offering a baseline wage?
Okay, you all could start a burger joint that pays employees a baseline wage + commission. Many potential employees would still prefer the flat paycheck especially when the company is just starting and is risky. Many companies already do this so I hope you all don't think this is some kind of new idea.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 12:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by allinontheturn
We were talking about income inequality ... distributional effects. You can make up all kinds of "stories" in your head where you create a bunch more wealth in the economy to justify the increase in earnings for a person. But if you want to think about distributional effects you need to hold the wealth of the economy constant. Otherwise you have too many moving parts and it obfuscates what you're trying to think about. It is literally impossible for me to make this any clearer so I won't try again.
No wonder why you think income inequality is a problem. Assuming 0% economic growth while analyzing the effects of laws that effect wealth distribution and economic growth is ridiculous.

As an example, people that are pro-tax-cuts like the idea of tax cuts because they believe long-term the economy will grow and therefore tax receipts won't go down and people will have more money to spend. Ignoring their reasoning behind supporting this law is silly - no matter if you believe it is true. You are just having a dishonest conversation.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 12:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bahbahmickey
You are just having a dishonest conversation.
You're the one who made this claim:

Quote:
Originally Posted by bahbahmickey
Income inequality has never and will never be a significant problem in a country as developed & free as the US. How are you worse off if your neighbor's income goes from $40k/yr to $4M/yr?
Now you're trying to shift the goalposts and say that the reason your neighbor's income goes from $40k/yr to $4M/yr is endogenous to the problem? Who's having the dishonest conversation again?

Quote:
Originally Posted by bahbahmickey
As an example, people that are pro-tax-cuts like the idea of tax cuts because they believe long-term the economy will grow and therefore tax receipts won't go down and people will have more money to spend. Ignoring their reasoning behind supporting this law is silly - no matter if you believe it is true. You are just having a dishonest conversation.
Practically nobody believes this. That's why the CBO said the recent tax cut will add $1.4T to the debt.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 12:54 PM
Holy ****, it just occurred to me that you probably think all markets are perfectly competitive etc etc and that income is a direct consequence of productivity in an economy. So it's only natural that the increase from $40k to $4M is a result of the neighbor's increased productivity - like tautologically.

That's adorable.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 01:17 PM
lol
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 01:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by allinontheturn
Now you're trying to shift the goalposts and say that the reason your neighbor's income goes from $40k/yr to $4M/yr is endogenous to the problem? Who's having the dishonest conversation again?

Practically nobody believes this. That's why the CBO said the recent tax cut will add $1.4T to the debt.
People tend not to have huge raises without taking a promotion, changing jobs or creating something very valuable for the economy. Assuming the economy isn't effected by someone jumping to $4m from of $40k (especially in your example of 2 ppl) is illogical.

Come the hell on believing the CBO on projections. I'm guessing you are surprised that a federal agency tends to favor a bigger government?

"While it is true that the CBO uses economic
models that are “politically” non-partisan, it is also true that the
models it uses favor more spending and higher taxation. They
assume government spending boosts economic growth and see
few negative economic effects from tax hikes. These models,
the people who defend them and the politicians that allow them
to be used consistently bias policy toward a bigger government,
with less faith in the private sector."

Quote:
Originally Posted by allinontheturn
Holy ****, it just occurred to me that you probably think all markets are perfectly competitive etc etc and that income is a direct consequence of productivity in an economy. So it's only natural that the increase from $40k to $4M is a result of the neighbor's increased productivity - like tautologically.

That's adorable.
nope.

Last edited by bahbahmickey; 06-12-2018 at 01:51 PM.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 02:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ScreaminAsian
lol
Sometimes I forget that online a cliffs notes understanding of Atlas Shrugged passes for economic expertise.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 03:30 PM
cliffs of your last 3 posts:

you: mickey, you shifted some goalposts. The CBO says a bigger budget for them and the rest of the federal government is good so we all should agree to give them more money.
you: mickey, I believe that you think all markets are perfectly competitive & income is perfectly correlated to production.
hero: I do not believe either of those.
you: you only think you understand economics because you read some specific book
me: I have never heard of that book.

What random accusation is coming next?
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 03:48 PM
half of all muricans have < $1k savings or something like that
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 04:12 PM
Thanks Obama
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-12-2018 , 06:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bahbahmickey
What random accusation is coming next?
You're a terrible poster who is once again making dumb political arguments in an inappropriate manner for the forum you're posting in - something that has already resulted in you being exiled multiple times from other parts of 2+2.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-13-2018 , 01:05 AM
Im gonna watch The Founder! per my main man aiott's recommendation

Hey, OP and bahbah booey mickey

Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-13-2018 , 11:06 AM
yayyyy expensive soccer festival wooohooo!!
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-13-2018 , 11:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by zikzak
You're a terrible poster who is once again making dumb political arguments in an inappropriate manner for the forum you're posting in - something that has already resulted in you being exiled multiple times from other parts of 2+2.
LoL, I just read his user profile. Dude can't even get along with people in POG without leaking his dumb political takes onto the keyboard.

Quote:
Originally Posted by bahbahmickey
You lost credibility when you said you are worse off when your neighbor got a pay raise because of "Scarcity." The economy isn't a zero sum game.
This one's my favorite so far itt. Just so aggressively wrong
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-13-2018 , 01:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tuma
yayyyy expensive soccer festival wooohooo!!
GOATrump warned me about responses like this...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=daOH-pTd_nk
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-13-2018 , 01:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by allinontheturn

This one's my favorite so far itt. Just so aggressively wrong
It's as if economic textbooks don't include a passage on scarcity on the page before the production possibility frontier.

Part of me wishes to give in to the bozo reality spoonfed by political happenstance. It might be fun to live with a 2-bit conscience and stack huge piles of cash.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-13-2018 , 02:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bahbahmickey
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tuma
yayyyy expensive soccer festival wooohooo!!
Mexico is gonna pay for it.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote
06-13-2018 , 02:52 PM
Hosting is the only way the US can qualify for a berth.
Trump/Shaq Infinity Thread Quote

      
m