No, two villagers other than myself.

I think JD is a villager

Why?

tbh its mainly based on his posts today. Wolves can discuss game mechanics as well ofc, but somehow I don't think thats in JDs wolf game.

I'm going to need more than that. It's just so easy for wolves to post about game mechanics. I think there is some stuff that looks good for him but that isn't it.

Ok, starting now, not going to comment too much, but going to take a ton of notes, will post them if we dont no lynch, will wait till after if we dont, as I dont expect I am a NK target.

But wanted to quote this post, its the only day we have a legitimate w/v wagon EOD.

Dean Voters Alive: Anarchist, Supine, UAW
HiFi Voters Alive: Fnord, JD
Non voter: Herbie.

Both dead wolves voted Dean FWIW

LOL at me coming back to thread and am a topic of conversation.

You just keep talking about how J.D. is a wolf without any logic, hence I thought you were suspicious.

Got through about 400 posts last night.

Have one question: Zayana mentioned a game she and Sun were wolves, and Mikey and Supine were peeked villager, anyone know the game?

Also, I am going to keep some thoughts to myself, but can't resist asking some questions.

Herbie, why did you decide not to make reads the first day?

Well, there has not been a huge amount of effort put into finding wolves today, that's for sure. (I know I haven't done much since Friday, but I have already reread the thread at least twice since D3.)

Anarchist seems like the only one genuinely looking for wolves right now.

I keep waiting on some real substantive follow ups to all these "don't rush things, I need to go reread" posts, but I am not seeing it.

I seriously don't mind lynching today, even though nothing has been done, because frankly I don't see anything changing. I'll try to skim the thread again at work.

The biggest down side to lynching today (just thought of this) is that probably only 3 or 4 people vote. It's going to be very easy for the wolves to manipulate any voting going on.

Anarchist what do you think? I am still inclined to just lynch today. I don't think anything gets clearer tomorrow, and I think Herbie is on crack if he thinks the night kill is going to be one of the 4 players on the table. (4 players being Herbie, UAW, JD, me, ldo).

I think there is a merit to lynching today rather than waiting for no lynch, but I'm still not sure which is better.

If we no lynch, we *might* get extra info (wolves kill someone, we re-read their posts to see why they were killed). However, then we get into a weird situation where there are 2 wolves and 3 villas left, and so it will be hard to vote. If a villa votes for another villa, the game ends right there. If we lynch today, even if someone makes a mistake vote the game doesn't auto end. (Worst that can happen is both wolves jump on that person and it becomes a tie, but if wolves lose flip they are outted).

OK, I hate hate hate hate hate this post.

JD - I am 400 posts through 2500ish post game.... Yeah, there was this mention of a game with these players, 2 of which are dead and the other of which is being effectively cleared here, anyone know where I can find it?


Seriously, why are you even thinking about reading another game when you are barely into your reread of this one? OK, so you don't have supine cleared maybe, fine, but that still makes no sense at all.

Basically my thought is that since this is a vanilla game and the seer was killed early, it's really hard to figure out who the wolves are other than by finding an egregious post someone made. I've re-read many pages of this thread a lot and have yet to find something that stands out as someone being 100% wolfy. Just little things here and there that point to certain people but are far from definitive. Unfortunately, people have been avoiding posting so there's not a ton to work with.

Like, where is everyone? They all just keep saying they're going to "post something HUGE and GAMEBREAKING later." UAW? Herbie? JD? I mean this is a totally vanilla game ffs I don't know if there is even a way it can be definitively solved unless someone really ****ed up or posted lolcats, we're just going on hunches. People who are trying to help the village should be posting to clear themselves, not hiding.

I think it is JD and Herbie right now. Just my pre coffee instinct.

Gotta shower and get to work, but I will be here all day. (I was lurking yesterday waiting for something to happen, today I will make something happen).

Just be careful not to vote (other than "no vote today") because a bad vote could end the game.

A ****ing Men.

I'm out, I might actually be gone all day. If I don't make it back before eod just stop posting when night falls and I will reveal when I'm back home if there is something to reveal.

I will give plenty of notice, but I think I am voting for a player today. I think.

I think you are the night kill tonight because everyone is clearing you pretty much and you are the only one really active.

Really gotta get ready for work now, bbl.

fnord,

If you decide to vote today, please vote Herbie. I don't think there is any chance he is a villager.

Reads? Not saying you're incorrect but...

Villas:

Anarchist
fnord
Supine

Wolves:

Herbie
J.D.

I have basically reread the whole thread concentrating on the live players and that is what I have come up with.

I'm willing to lose if anarchist or Supine is a wolf.

I didn't know if the last wolf was fnord or J.D. before rereading, but now I believe it has to be J.D.

I would like to no lynch today so I have more time to present a case on each of them. I work the graveyard shift so I will be going to sleep soon and don't know if I will have time to do that today.