Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
The way to tell the difference, I think, is whether there's sufficient thought being put into why automatic lynches should be automatic
If everyone is just like "lol obvious wolves lynch vyk and sooted ldo" then it's a problem, but in this case there's significant reasoning behind why each of them is actually probably a wolf here to the point that it would surprise me more than a little if they weren't both wolves, and either one of them coming up villager doesn't make the other any more likely to actually be a villager, so it's not like if Sooted comes up village that would make me really want to reevaluate Vyk all that much, or vice versa.
If somehow they're both village then village is never winning this game no matter how many times we go over things imo
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Also if they're both wolves the remaining "wolf team" consists of exactly one player, much easier to just try to blend into the crowd and hope to win it that way then trying to rock the boat now and risk outing yourself to save already doomed teammates, especially with the seer dead.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Alright I've been waiting to talk about this to see if it was necessary but apparently it is. The reason I want to lynch Vyk today instead of tomorrow is because I'm not at all sure that he's coming back to the thread - he bowed out of two other games last night that he was signed up for after having a fight with someone in a signup thread and at least appears to have left POG for now
If people had a strong preference for lynching sooted over vyk on the merits then it's obviously best to go with the strongest read first but it really seems silly to go through the trouble of potentially subbing a guy out if he's definitely going to be the next lynch anyways.
Also the flip side of that is that I find that people tend to want to give people who sub a chance to "be villagery" instead of just auto-lynching them, and I've seen wolves sub in as assumed auto lynches and go on to win enough times that I really hate the idea of doing anything with a potential sub other than auto lynching them given the evidence against vyk
So yeah, that's why I think we should lynch Vyk first
I mean just look at this exchange, he's trying to complicate things and throw blame off of himself, onto them, i mean i would be ****ing shocked if he wasn't a wolf.
