WW: Independence Day - Page 26 - Puzzles and Other Games Forum

lurking isn't really inherently wolfy, and there's also nothing really that wolfy about his votes last night or his explanation this morning. I guess I can kind of understand the logic behind zurvan's argument, but it also bothers me that it seems like the kind of case you arrive at reasoning backwards (start by assuming gtpitch=wolf and then interpret along those lines) than frontwards.

I saw something wolfy, I pointed it out, and why I thought it was wolfy. It all comes at once. His response - not villagery. I mean, dude has 9 posts, 3 of them today. There's not a lot to work on there, so I can hardly build up a stunning wall of deductive logic.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:21 PM

#627

BitchiBee

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 24,622

Quote:

Originally Posted by VayaConDios

Yeah. I won't be around most of today, but if I get back by EOD I'll announce who I'm going to NK

Don't

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:21 PM

#628

Zurvan

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 36,260

Quote:

Also it seems like a distraction from a more straightforward idea about resolving the way the wagons went after the claim (i.e resolving icon)

What do we learn if Icon is a wolf? What if he's a villager?

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:23 PM

#629

well named

poorly undertitled

Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 78,077

if he's a villager not much (depending on vaya's role). If he's a wolf we learn a lot because of the chinese fire drill. Also he's wolfy, which is a reason to lynch him by itself.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:23 PM

#630

BitchiBee

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 24,622

And Gtpitch is a villager, get off of him please.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:24 PM

#631

well named

poorly undertitled

Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 78,077

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zurvan

also this is a straw man, I'm not saying you can't read someone as wolf without a "stunning wall of deductive logic". I'm saying the thought process behind the read sounds wolfy to me, and gtpitch not so much.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:28 PM

#632

Zurvan

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 36,260

Quote:

Originally Posted by well named

What thought process? Seriously. The post was wolfy. I said why. It's (necessarily) based on little. You disagree, thus you think I'm wolfy for coming up with a flaky case. You're assuming I'm wrong and making up a case on a villager. Begging the question, imo.

Let's logical fallacy the whole thread; should be good fun.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:29 PM

#633

Zurvan

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 36,260

You don't think defending a villager RIGHT AT nightfall is wolfy? Not even a teency bit? It was 9:30 on the nose, he had to know there was no way to change the wagon by that point, so it reeks of trying to get villager points

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:33 PM

#634

well named

poorly undertitled

Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 78,077

Quote:

Let's logical fallacy the whole thread; should be good fun.

=D

fwiw when I say I find your thought process wolfy it's not really intended to be a logical argument at all. It's just a feel. And of course that's probably also true of your gtpitch read. I didn't criticise your case against gtpitch by saying it wasn't logical, I just said it felt wrong. I did say it was logically wrong to say my criticism is invalid for the reason you stated, i.e you mischaracterized my disagreement as being about the non-logicality when it wasn't.

misrepresentation also feels wolfy to me :P

But no I don't think defending a villager right at nightfall is wolfy at all really.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:36 PM

#635

Zurvan

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 36,260

Didn't mean to say you were criticizing my case because I didn't have logic behind it. I was exaggerating for effect.

Quote:

But no I don't think defending a villager right at nightfall is wolfy at all really.

crazy talk

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:49 PM

#636

BrownEyedGirl

Pooh-Bah

Join Date: Aug 2008 Posts: 3,983

Quote:

Originally Posted by well named

You're right. I'm doing it again. I have a bad habit of auto assuming wolf and not trying to see it from the villager perspective.

Unvote.

I honestly do not know who to vote for. I will just keep trying. I'm going to be gone this eveing, but hope to be here before eod.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 03:55 PM

#637

coordi

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: May 2007 Posts: 22,831

Quote:

Originally Posted by BitchiBee

And Gtpitch is a villager, get off of him please.

you also lead the charge on aao

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:16 PM

#638

Zurvan

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 36,260

I'm off; should be back before eod

Lynch gt, lynch coordi.

Totally confused about BEG completely changing her game today. Need to think on it some more.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:33 PM

#639

DustinG

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Nov 2004 Posts: 31,442

zurvan,

what about biggerboat?

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:36 PM

#640

McAvoy

banned

Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 46,476

I just finished my re read. On page 1, I decided that cordi is a villager. When I later found out this is his first game, it solidifies my read and if he is a wolf, I will drop my ego for one month. Thats how confident I am of my read.

Other villas

BEG
64
Zurvan
Aries (because I came across a dudd post that I was like wtf and I had it quoted, then I seen aries pick up on it)
wellnamed

Other than that, if OTI or Digger ever turn up wolf, we have to lynch the other cuz they could be w/w.

I think dud is my strongest wolf lean but I'd prefer to kill VCD today cuz I don't want him viging another villager tonight.

VCD

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:37 PM

#641

McAvoy

banned

Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 46,476

Quote:

Originally Posted by DustinG

zurvan,

what about biggerboat?

If he's a wolf, let him spew.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:38 PM

#642

McAvoy

banned

Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 46,476

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dudd

While I haven't played with him before, aao pulled this same random vote crap in his only previous completed long game, and he ended up villa in that. He did have the exact same discussion in that game about why voting random is a bad idea, so he should know by now that voting for a random afk player is a bad idea. Either he just doesn't care about being helpful for the village by sticking to this so clearly flawed voting style, or he's trying to remain consistent with his previous villa play as a wolf, neither of which is helpful for the village.

Vote aao.

This is a terrible reason to vote aao imo and I can see a wolf making up this type of lame excuse to vote for him. aka I'm doing this to teach him a lesson, that he should have learnt by now.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:39 PM

#643

McAvoy

banned

Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 46,476

Quote:

Originally Posted by LuckayLuck

We're going to end up lynching a villager get lynched today almost certainly. If we get a wolf lynched it's because there seems to be low activity in the thread?

shroop?

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:47 PM

#644

sixfour

should be called sevenfour

Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 74,754

i do not like the current wagons fwiw

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:55 PM

#645

OnThInIcE911

€øñƒµ§êÐ

Join Date: Jun 2006 Posts: 27,991

Ok well I think I like

MCavoy

better than Dusting

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:58 PM

#646

LuckayLuck

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 36,907

Hi guys, only read up to the nightkills.
I just wanted to say that this day one was possibly the worst I have ever seen. That is all.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 04:59 PM

#647

DustinG

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Nov 2004 Posts: 31,442

Luckay,

Just trust me and vote for bigger

Quote

07-03-2009 , 05:03 PM

#648

BitchiBee

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 24,622

Quote:

Originally Posted by coordi

you also lead the charge on aao

and?

Quote

07-03-2009 , 05:05 PM

#649

Dudd

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Sep 2004 Posts: 54,241

Quote:

Originally Posted by McAvoy

This is a terrible reason to vote aao imo and I can see a wolf making up this type of lame excuse to vote for him. aka I'm doing this to teach him a lesson, that he should have learnt by now.

Should I just claim tone like everyone else on day one, that's pretty unimpeachable? It wasn't that he needed to be taught a lesson, but that he had already had this discussion multiple times and should by this point have changed his day one game unless he was trying to remain consistent with his previous villa play. Conversely, if he really was villa, voting him off can't be that big a mistake because he wouldn't be that helpful to the village anyways.

Quote

07-03-2009 , 05:27 PM

#650

LuckayLuck

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 36,907

For the record before I delete him off my spreadsheet:

GT1T repeated that he thought Jennifer Garner, McAvoy, and VayaConDios were wolves about three times.

Quote

Page 26 of 75

First

6 16 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 36 46

Last

Post Reply Subscribe

...

Page 26 of 75

First

6 16 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 36 46

Last