Holy cow lol, I had no idea so many words I have been picking have already been done! Favorites like PHONE, ABOUT, and UNDER have had their glory days.
So for something that hasn't been done, I will go with SPORT
For those of you who got TINEA to PINCH in 2, it may have looked pretty lucky but y'all did not pass over many legit options. If you eliminated double letter words like KINKY, SINUS, etc as first picks, then the most realistic options for common words were:
MINOR
MINUS PINCH
PINKY
WINCH
WINDY
Just posting cause sometimes things look flukey, but when you start looking are common word structures and legit options, many of the choices people make have more EV than one might think. And, that PINCH jumped out for 5 people is not that surprising, really.