WEREWOLF 1 - Page 44 - Puzzles and Other Games Forum

Alright, villagers. Where are we? Nick was hot to lynch jba. Who are our best leads now?

jba
kramer
pizowd
tightplayer
other?

Let's start speculating......

Damn. This was my post before MW outed himself. I just needed to last a couple of more nights :0

Good job tightplay/piz! Congratulations.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 02:29 PM

#1077

Shajen

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Nov 2004 Posts: 7,482

poor Mowz.

Mowz protects MacDaddy Warsaw. Mowz was killed by werewolves.

WAPAZONIED.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 02:47 PM

#1078

pudley4

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Oct 2002 Posts: 6,828

On Day 2, both 4_2 and I wanted the seer to check out piz

Quote

04-10-2006 , 02:49 PM

#1079

pudley4

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Oct 2002 Posts: 6,828

Sorry guys, I thought all werewolves had to check in each night, that's why tightplay wasn't on my list.

GG piz.

great job gorie!

Quote

04-10-2006 , 02:58 PM

#1080

billygrippo

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 8,570

HOOWWLL!!1

Quote

04-10-2006 , 03:19 PM

#1081

Lethe

journeyman

Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 362

Great game guys ... I've been following this from the beginning. I was -positive- that Keikwai and Tightplay were the wolves. I suspected Piz but his rationalization near the end changed my mind. Good job Piz.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 03:20 PM

#1082

kyro

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: May 2004 Posts: 30,354

Quote:

HOOWWLL!!1

You are my hero. Well played.

(If anyone is interested, there was a wild game that went on in the STTF forum. Check out WWII in that forum for more brilliant play.)

Quote

04-10-2006 , 03:39 PM

#1083

rbdog

journeyman

Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 301

Quote:

HOOWWLL!!1

Very well done, my new wolf-friend. I lost many hours of sleep to thinking about why/what you were doing.

That crappy thing is - I voted for you first - and then, playing with no confidence, just grasping to straws I thought Keiki and Tight were together.

Congrats to you, and too bad for me and our humble village.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 03:51 PM

#1084

madnak

Cooler than Sammy Hagar

Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 19,742

Nice. You were under suspicion the whole time and you pulled it off. And tightplay was at the bottom of the suspect list.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 04:52 PM

#1085

theTourne

grinder

Join Date: Sep 2004 Posts: 400

well played (piz especially). that was fun to watch.

thinking back now, i think my favorite part was when gorie reminded the players that an equal numbers of werewolves and villagers = WW victory, and piz pretended to be surprised. he said something like "oh [censored]"

Quote

04-10-2006 , 05:51 PM

#1086

gorie

Pooh-Bah

Join Date: Mar 2005 Posts: 5,473

haha i liked that too.
piz played pretty good, it was funny because i think people tried to get votes on him a couple time but he managed to sneak out of it every time without any real attention.

for the most part the villagers were all attacking each other so it seemed pretty easy for the wolves to just sit back and enjoy

i also thought macdaddy did some good detective work as seer, he was the only one who saw what i thought was an obvious link between talentdeficit's death and jesusarenque being a werewolf early on.

it was cool to watch it play out knowing who everyone was.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 08:29 PM

#1087

zephed

banned

Join Date: May 2005 Posts: 2,310

Quote:

crap! why'd I change my vote from tightplay to rbdog!

A: piz pwned in a big way

gg all

I told you guys. The only vote you guys gave me was Keikiwai. Also, kiki, maybe you could have done some things to make it more obvious you were a ww. I can't believe I voted for you. As soon as I left the computer, I realized my vote was a losing vote. One of us (piz, rbdog, me) was in fact a ww, and all three of us ended up voting for kiki, did not make sense but I did not figure it out until later.

I wish I could have been more convincing advocating piz as a ww.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 08:31 PM

#1088

zephed

banned

Join Date: May 2005 Posts: 2,310

Quote:

HOOWWLL!!1

You switching from piz to kiki had me bummed. It also made me not trust you.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 08:32 PM

#1089

bobbyi

Pooh-Bah

Join Date: Nov 2003 Posts: 5,837

Quote:

Game Over. The werewolves won

None of this would have happened if you guys had listened to me. Remember this next time we have a disagreement.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 08:33 PM

#1090

zephed

banned

Join Date: May 2005 Posts: 2,310

Good job tightplay, I didn't really suspect you.

Piz very good job, I called you out a few times but you managed to avoid it.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 08:35 PM

#1091

4_2_it

Preventer

Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 24,744

Quote:

Game Over. The werewolves won

None of this would have happened if you guys had listened to me. Remember this next time we have a disagreement.

Next time try to remember not to wave a red flag in front of a lot of pissed off bulls.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 10:40 PM

#1092

theTourne

grinder

Join Date: Sep 2004 Posts: 400

Quote:

i also thought macdaddy did some good detective work as seer, he was the only one who saw what i thought was an obvious link between talentdeficit's death and jesusarenque being a werewolf early on.

I'd like to hear talentdeficit's take on this. He seemed to be claiming that he was seer. He said something like "vote for jesus now, and if I die tonight vote for him tomorrow." I guess it must have been a lucky guess? Since he picked jesus, the WWs figured he was indeed the seer and took him out.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 10:42 PM

#1093

jesusarenque

veteran

Join Date: Oct 2004 Posts: 2,311

Quote:

i also thought macdaddy did some good detective work as seer, he was the only one who saw what i thought was an obvious link between talentdeficit's death and jesusarenque being a werewolf early on.

Honestly, we were just picking people at random. I didn't even notice the jesus/talentdeficit connection until the villagers brought it up.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 10:55 PM

#1094

Toe-Knee

adept

Join Date: Jan 2005 Posts: 1,093

Quote:

************************************************** **********************

Game Over. The werewolves won

1: nation (werewolf) selected Alex Levin as the victim
1: Macdaddy Warsaw (seer) sought information about 4_2_it
1: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! (werewolf) selected Alex Levin as the victim
1: jesusarenque (werewolf) selected rbdog as the victim
1: tightplay (werewolf) selected Alex Levin as the victim
1: mowz (angel) protected mowz
1: the spirits revealed 4_2_it as a villager
1: Alex Levin was murdered by werewolves
2: Kramer voted for bobbyi
2: keikiwai voted for bobbyi
2: mowz voted for bobbyi
2: talentdeficit voted for jesusarenque--------Whoa!!! 27th level, huh.
2: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for bobbyi
2: Sightless voted for Sightless
2: Sightless voted for bobbyi
2: d10 voted for bobbyi
2: pudley4 voted for bobbyi
2: bobbyi voted for zephed
2: jesusarenque voted for talentdeficit----Whoa!!! 27th level, huh.
2: rbdog voted for bobbyi
2: Andrew Karpinski voted bobbyi
2: 4_2_it voted bobbyi
2: jesusarenque voted for bobbyi
2: Evans67 voted for bobbyi
2: bobbyi (a villager) was lynched
3: jesusarenque (werewolf) selected talentdeficit as the victim
3: mowz (angel) protected mowz
3: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! (werewolf) selected talentdeficit as the victim
3: Macdaddy Warsaw (seer) sought information about Kramer.
3: nation (werewolf) selected talentdeficit as the victim
3: the spirits revealed Kramer. as a villager
3: talentdeficit was murdered by werewolves
4: Sightless voted for 4_2_it
4: Toe-Knee voted for Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! I rule!
4: Nicholasp27 voted for Piz0wn0reD!!!!!!!
4: pudley4 voted for jba
4: jba voted for Nicholasp27
4: d10 voted for jba
4: jba voted for Piz0wn0red!!!!!!
4: jesusarenque voted for jba
4: Nicholasp27 voted for jba
4: nation voted Andrew Karpinksi
4: Toe-Knee voted for jba
4: d10 voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: jba voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: mic_check12 voted for rbdog
4: rbdog voted for jba
4: rbdog voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: mowz voted for jba
4: Toe-Knee voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: jesusarenque voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: mowz voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: Nicholasp27 voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: pudley4 voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: Evans67 voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: Kramer. voted for Andrew Karpinski
4: Andrew Karpinski (a villager) was lynched
5: mowz (angel) protected mowz
5: nation (werewolf) selected Nicholasp27 as the victim
5: jesusarenque (werewolf) selected Nicholasp27 as the victim
5: Macdaddy Warsaw (seer) sought information about jesusarenque
5: Piz0wn0red!!!!!! (werewolf) selected Nicholasp27 as the victim
5: the spirits revealed jesusarenque as a werewolf
5: Nicholasp27 was murdered by werewolves
6: Sightless voted for Kramer.
6: Macdaddy Warsaw voted for jesusarenque
6: rbdog voted for jesusarenque
6: jba voted for jesusarenque
6: Evans67 voted for jesusarenque
6: nation voted for jesusarenque
6: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for jesusarenque
6: keikiwai voted for jesusarenque
6: 4_2_it voted for jesusarenque
6: Toe-Knee voted for jesusarenque
6: Kramer. voted for jesusarenque
6: jesusarenque (a werewolf) was lynched
7: nation (werewolf) has selected keikiwai as the victim
7: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! (werewolf) has selected keikiwai as the victim
7: nation (werewolf) has selected 4_2_it as the victim
7: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! (werewolf) has selected 4_2_it as the victim
7: Macdaddy Warsaw (seer) sought information about nation
7: tightplay (werewolf) has selected 4_2_it as the victim
7: mowz (angel) protected Macdaddy Warsaw
7: the spirits revealed nation as a werewolf
7: 4_2_it was murdered by werewolves
8: Macdaddy Warsaw voted for nation
8: nation voted for Macdaddy Warsaw
8: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for nation
8: Kramer. voted for nation
8: jba voted for nation
8: Sightless voted for nation
8: Sightless voted for Macdaddy Warsaw
8: rbdog voted for nation
8: Sightless voted for nation
8: keikiwai voted for nation
8: mowz voted for nation
8: Evans67 voted for nation
8: nation (a werewolf) was lynched
9: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! (werewolf) selected mowz as the victim
9: Macdaddy Warsaw (seer) sought information about jba
9: mowz (angel) protected Macdaddy Warsaw
9: the spirits revealed jba as a villager
9: mowz (angel) was murdered by werewolves
10: Macdaddy Warsaw voted for Sightless
10: Evans67 voted for Sightless
10: Kramer. voted for Evans67
10: keikiwai voted for Sightless
10: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for Sightless
10: d10 voted fro Sightless
10: mic_check12 voted fro Piz0wn0reD!!!!!!
10: rbdog voted for Sightless
10: zephed voted for Sightless
10: jba voted for Sightless
10: Sightless (a villager) was lynched
11: MacDaddy Warsaw sought information about Evans67
11: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! has selected MacDaddy Warsaw as the victim
11: the spirits revealed Evans67 as a villager
11: MacDaddy Warsaw was murdered by werewolves
12: jba voted for Evans67
12: Evans67 voted for keikiwai
12: Kramer. voted for Evans67
12: rbdog voted for Evans67
12: rbdog voted for Toe-Knee
12: Kramer. voted for d10
12: PiZ0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for d10
12: jba voted for d10
12: tightplay voted for d10
12: keikiwai voted for d10
12: pudley4 voted for d10
12: zephed voted for d10
12: d10 (a villager) was lynched
13: tightplay (werewolf) selected jba as the victim
13: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! selected jba as the victim
13: jba was murdered by werewolves
14: rbdog voted for Evans67
14: Kramer. voted for Evans67
14: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for Evans67
14: Evans67 voted for keikiwai
14: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for Toe-Knee
14: tightplay voted for Toe-Knee
14: Kramer. voted for Toe-Knee
14: mic_check12 voted for Toe-Knee
14: rbdog voted for Toe-Knee
14: Evans67 voted for Toe-Knee
14: Toe-Knee (a villager) was lynched
15: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! (werewolf) has selected Kramer. as the victim
15: Kramer. (a villager) has been murdered by werewolves
16: rbdog voted for Evans67
16: Evans67 voted for rbdog
16: mic_check12 voted for Evans67
16: keikiwai voted for EVans67
16: Evans67 voted for keikiwai
16: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for Evans67
16: tightplay votes for Evans67
16: pudley4 votes for Evans67
16: Evans67 (a villager) was lynched
17: tightplay (werewolf) has selected pudley4 has the victim
17: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! (werewolf) has selected pudley4 as the victim
17: pudley4 (a villager) was murdered by werewolves
18: rbdog voted for keikiwai
18: tightplay voted for keikiwai
18: zephed voted for Piz0wn0reD!!!!!!
18: keikiwai voted for tightplay
18: rbdog voted for PiZ0wn0reD!!!!!!
18: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for mic_check12
18: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for rbdog
18: tightplay voted for rbdog
18: keikiwai voted for rbdog
18: rbdog voted for keikiwai
18: mic_check12 voted for keikiwai
18: Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! voted for keikiwai
18: zephed voted for keikiwai
18: keikiwai (a villager) was lynched
19: rbdog was murdered by werewolves

Game Over. The werewolves won

I shoulda stuck w/ my first vote. Plus I picked tightplay AND Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! in the comentary thread. Bah you guys shoulda let me explain myself

! Anyway great game Gorie, even though everyone else in OOT seems to hate it I think it's awesome. Thanks for letting me play and twas fun everyone!

EDIT: Also what made you wolfs jump on me? I see you both voted for me first when I was lynched.

Quote

04-10-2006 , 10:56 PM

#1095

pudley4

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Oct 2002 Posts: 6,828

Quote:

i also thought macdaddy did some good detective work as seer, he was the only one who saw what i thought was an obvious link between talentdeficit's death and jesusarenque being a werewolf early on.

It was either a lucky guess, or (more likely) he saw a lot of PM activity from jesus

Quote

04-10-2006 , 11:10 PM

#1096

rbdog

journeyman

Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 301

In so many OOT topics, its clear immediately those who are skilled communicators/writers and those who are stupidos.

I think Piz' ability to lead me and others into this false sense of "going in the right direction" was his strength.

And you can only do that if you're not stupidazo.

A well timed bluff will put the table on tilt much more than a series of powerful hands...

Thanks again, Gorie, and I hope to play again.