Players:
keikiwai (2 votes) voted for rbdog
mic_check12 voted for keikiwai
Piz0wn0reD!!!!!! (1 votes) voted for rbdog
rbdog (3 votes) voted for keikiwai
tightplay voted for rbdog
zephed voted for Piz0wn0reD!!!!!!


oops, there. i hope that's right now

Assuming piz is a villager, I don't understand why he'd vote for you. Keikiwai would be a much more obvious selection. Piz, why didn't you vote for keikiwai instead of rbdog? Why did you vote for rbdog? Even if rbdog is a ww, keikiwai is more likely, no?

hmmm, I'm obviously the swing voter here. Since there are three voters for you, that means at least one villager voted for you. I would like to hear an explanation by each of your voters for why they think it is you, and why you are the BEST choice at this point.

This sucks, it's obvious this game will be determined by my decision.

Very suspicious post. 3 of the 4 players you suspected were villagers. I should have spoken up about piz earlier, and not gone with the group think.

EDIT: Where'd you go rbdog? I noticed you were online and typing a response to this thread, now you are logged off?

I dont know if you will hear from Piz, Keiki or Tight, but I think this:

I think Piz voted for me because he thought I was trying too hard to sell him 'something'. Me thinks he doth protest too much, that kinda thing.

But please notice that quite soon after Piz made a big deal about me, and saying I was a wolf, that Keiki and Tight jumped immediately to follow.

Neither of them have offered reasons why I am a wolf, other than to suggest that my extreme posting was a shill for wolfishness.

Its not, I was just trying to isolate any pairs that moved together and I think that happened.

In a room full of liars, the one telling the truth is going to stand out. I am a villager and decided to play this game as the straight one. Theres no 27th level thinking with my current proposition, only a reasonably solid reduction process.

Mic - he has not played enough, or been involved in some votes to be the wolf. I think at least two Nights came and went in the deep of the UK mornings. If he is a wolf, he let others vote for him.

Zephed - If you are the wolf, I will tap the felt, say good hand and admit we all got outplayed.

I think pudley was right on. I feel strongly that Keiki is the wolf primarily because of the vote-trade, tandem vote for me after Piz broke the cherry on me.

Change your vote from Piz to Keiki. One of those that have voted for me will come over and make it 4.

If either you and Mic are wolves, well.... good game. Had me from hello.

Vote for Keiki, zeph...

Some more evidence?

I'm almost switching my vote to you rbdog. That is a lot of bs about the 7th (you meant 6th) vote. You made the fifth vote here and allowed a confused villager to put it over the top.

I dont understand what youre asking here.

This was the 4th vote, right before yours rbdog.

So quick to start off the day.

2nd vote for evans, only 10 minutes after rbdog's.

I am not a wolf.
I am not a wolf.
I am not a wolf.

If you vote for me, the game is over. Then, when we play again, sometime during that game, I would ask that you post,

"Hey, I voted for RBdog and it ended the game, so I'm believing what he says here now..."

(Kinda like a voucher for later on...)

Whatever. Now I half want you to vote for me so that I can read your apology.

Your 4th vote for me = wolves win.

6 minutes later
Very quick decision by the ww's. rbdog posted shortly before and after these decisions.

Here's a post shortly after the decision. Really weak argument, sounds like you are just trying to push the vote somewhere and deflect attention away from yourself. If I were a villager, I would not mind being lynched at all if it was able to provide so much information for the villagers. I really think that's where our strategy failed. We kept on voting for players that would not reveal much information, just whoever seemed fishy. More strategy next time villagers.

We should have hanged piz, kiki, and rbdog before d10 and evans.

this was bcuz Ive been unhealthily obsessed with this game.

No more yanky my wanky.

Vote for me or Keiki.

Blood on your hands.

Keiki=wolf. RB=Villager.

Sounds like a wolf.

Yup. He's a wolf alright.

You had two votes here, and were not finished off. That means at least one of us three is a ww. rb, piz or zephed are ww's. Why?

Well, if you assume all three of us are villagers, the two ww's would have finished the game immediately. Bam! I am willing to throw my name in with you two if it means some lost villager realizes a mistake. FACT: zephed, pizownored!!111!!1omgwtfstfulolrolfslotboom, rbdog: ONE OF US IS A WOLF

Further, does everyone agree that I am almost certainly a villager? If so, that means it is 50% chance that rbdog and piz are werewolves. Can we jump on the pizownored bandwagon instead of the keikiwai bandwagon? WHY NOT?

================================================== ==========================
For the other three villagers out there, please go over this in your head and re-examine. If you don't trust me, you still should consider the original fact in bold lettering. I would like some input from the quiet ones in this thread. I WILL NOT VOTE UNTIL mic_check, tightplay, piz, and keikiwai respond to this series of posts by me.

If piz is the ww, I think either Keikiwai/tightplay are acting with him since they also voted for rbdog. So in this scenario, we have a confused villager voting with the ww's. So one is acting with him, the other is just confused. I'd bet tightplay was the confused one If I had to pick.

Now, if rbdog is the ww, who is the other? Most likely me, no (if there's another, someone point it out plz)? Two wolves starting a vote on a villager and trying to confuse another villager. From my perspective, since I know I am not a ww, the other ww did not join his partner. So I don't think it's that likely he's a ww because wouldn't they want to get the vote going? I do not think rbdog is a very good vote RIGHT NOW at all, which is what is bothering me. Why does he have 3 votes? Why is there a villager voting with the wolves? Or alternately, why am I not voting with three villagers? Or even more out there, why would the wolves split their votes?

The same analysis applies if you assume I am a ww. rb is my accomplice, read above, yadda yadda.

I will be back in a few hours, maybe not until morning. Sorry about making the enormous flurry of posts.

One final thought, I do not see why we couldn't switch our keikiwai votes to pizownored. I'm leaning towards keikiwai at this point if that is what I have to do though. Hopefully their will be some vote movement when I make a decision.

Thoroughly confused,
zephed.

***NOT A PLAYER (OBVIOUSLY)***

you know how sometimes everyone goes nuts about a new show and you aren't interested in it and you ignore it and it keeps getting more and more popular so finally you rent a dvd to see what the [censored] everyone was so excited about and then you get hooked on it so you rent the whole season and you stay up late to finish it and then you get to the last dvd and it isn't there? yeah.

***NOT A PLAYER***

i just read over all the most recent posts and they further prove my case. rbdog and zeph are almost 100% certain to be the wolves.

if rbdog is a wolf, and zeph is a wolf, he will not vote for rbdog. he has not.

if rbdog is a villager, zeph and mic cannot be a wolf.

this means that the only possible wolf pairs are:

rbdog and zeph

rbdog and mic

keikwai and tighplay (or me and one of them, since to any villager everyone is still a suspect)

you guys need to trust me on this. rbdog is the favorite to be a WW. im super duper sure that its him and zeph based on zeph not voting for him. however if zeph is a villager, him not wanting to cast the final vote (and possible making us lose) is a reasonable and valid argument. if that truely is the case, rbdog and mic become the favorite.

either way our best possible play is to lynch rbdog. he is a wolf!

okokokokokk i just thought of something


rbdog has 3 votes. if he really is a villager, 2 of the votes for him MUST BE WOLVES!

the last bunch of posts have only been zeph and rbdog. this either proves that they cant both be wolves, or they are super super good at being WWs. i dont like to give credit for smarts (sorry guys).

lets assume that rbdog is a villager. if i was a WW i would play it cool and let zeph vote for rbdog thus winning the game.

noone has posted but you two in forever, i have been gone all day.

ok rbdog. im gonna have to trust you here. i think that the WWs are keikwai and tighplay. at least it is as likely as you and zeph.

i switch my vote to keikwai

why are you starting w/ the assumption rbdog is a villager?

if he is a villager than your assumption is correct... however you used the same logic to say rbdog and zeph are ww when the two of them voted together.... that reasoning convinced me to vote for rbdog....

basically, you can't use that logic twice, since it is different people making the votes.

i do think the x-change between zeph and rbdog is strange, since i thought the 2 of them were wolves....

anyway, do not vote for me. the villagers will lose if i get lynched.

the fact that rbdog has not yet been lynched increases the likelihood that he is a wolf (since the other wolf is not willing to vote for him)... if he is not then the two other people who voted for him besides me are wolf

i touched on this: "rbdog has 3 votes. if he really is a villager, 2 of the votes for him MUST BE WOLVES!"

you were quick to vote for rbdog once i called him out. all that you and tighplay needed was one other person to vote, which they didnt.

you have not replied to this thread in some time now (like 5 hours). yet you readily reply to my calling you out. because now you are not safe now. before i switched my vote, you were safe: tightplay (the otehr WW) wouldnt vote for you. you wouldnt vote for you. that means that zeph and i both had to vote for you to lynch you. i wasnt budging. zeph wanted to but never did.

i think that you and tightplay are the favorite.