No. The only way the werewolves win is to dwindle our numbers. They will take an easy kill because if they can't kill MD, then they lose a chance.

If someone must die every night, then they will try to kill MD every night first (which would be pretty lame)so he will have to be protected every night.

gorie should clarify before the next night phase is over.

***ALSO NOT A PLAYER***

Couldn't agree more. I should've gone to bed a long time ago, this game is the primary reason I'm up. Sorry for cluttering the thread, but I love you all.

**ALSO NOT A PLAYER***

gorie,

Don't we have enough votes for a lynching yet?

Didn't I already say WW's would not hit me and then the reason would come back was that I was actually a werewolf? I think you should all be suspicious of jba at this point (you guys might have been on the right track after all).

I had other ideas for who to "see" but if you would prefer, I could look at jba tonight. If it comes back that he is a villager, I can give you my "educated guess" and the reasoning behind them on who to lynch tomorrow.

I didn't want to affect the "see" voting, but I think this is too egregious to pass mentioning it.

Well, I think either kramer or I are next on the menu. I am heading up to retire. I will check back after dinner.

Good job MD!!!!!

huh ? it is night.

This thread moves quickly

I agree jba is worth checking out only because if that he is one then the other two are most likely the silent ones. Check him out.

4_2_it,
good points. after getting the rules clarified from gorie, I think the person who dies tonight may not matter so much. In some ways it does, but I'm not going to say why until tomorrow.

I concur sir, let's go Lesko.

MW,

I think there are a lot of villagers that distrust me more than they trust you. You might be in a lot of hot water if you vouch for me tomorrow

I'm startin to get bad feelings about this whole Macdaddy Warsaw situation.

Obviously the werewolves decided to out one of their own to guarentee a werewolf lives forever.

hahahaha I'm like 100% sure we're going to run into another seer tomorrow.

3 things.

1. villagers should probably keep talking at night to a minimum
2. jba has said some weird things.
3. I hope the angel is smart.

nh macdaddy

Yeah, but it's done nothing to relieve suspicion.

If another seer does crop up tomorrow though, I'm totally serious you guys need to shoot him down, because I think my logic is excellent. If he's the real seer, then you kill the seer, but you know for sure I'm a wolf. If he's a wolf, then it was pointless.

That said, I wouldn't be surprisd if a seer pops up sometime soon and says something along the lines of "I just consulted on Macdaddy Warsaw, he's a werewolf, lynch him." This is the only thing that makes sense. If a seer comes up saying to lynch somebody besides me, that's just bizarre.

Of course, none of this talking out the whole story is doing anything to make you trust me more.

Anyway, unles you guys think it's detrimental, I COULD use some ideas for who to look at tonight. It's a tough decision as it is, and having my "Werewolf life" hang in the balance makes it much more difficult to pull the trigger. I thought outing jesusarenque when he wasn't mentioned as a WW at all would make it easier to believe who I was, but it obviously hasn't done that at all.

jba
pizowd
zephed

any of those is fine.

Argh...There's a 4th name that hasn't been mentioned at all in the running. And I feel very strongly that the 4th person could be a WW. If you'd like me to name them, I could nad you guys could deliberate, or I could choose and when the results come back give the answer plus reasoning.

I don't want to hold the game up too much for deliberation, but I have a hunch on this one (like before).

What about d10? Haven't seen him in a while. I'm thinking him or pizowd.

less talking by villagers at night is better, i think. although i lean toward checking on people that we don't have a lot of info on.

Out with it, the hunch shouldn't turn the game around at all.

It's you.

i suggested nation as a defender of jba.

i say macdaddy has 3 days to find us a werewolf. if he can't, we whack him. if it turns out he's the seer, we have 4_2 and kramer as safe, and the three new people he sees. if he's a werewolf, we go after 4_2 and kramer.