I was actually worried you would guess too high, and was debating going with "overripe banana" instead, so I was a bit surprised that 4 and 5 were being thrown around, since it is still a solid.
I consider bananas more mushy than gooey, so I would put slime as the meme 1, then go up to like syrup, then caramel, peanut butter, porridge, ice cream, mashed potatoes, etc all at the low to mid-low part of the scale.
But I thought 7 was one the hardest numbers to clue for, so I'm glad y'all got there.