no lynch

That's actually a great idea. But need some more time for everyone to post first. Forcing the seer to claim is bad, and the game is being played too weird right now.

I think I'm voting a wolf. I'm a stick with that.

Probably won't be able to post anymore from now until Monday.

Wolf claim obviously.

Peace bitches.

mechanically speaking it may be correct to lynch someone who isn't a potential seer or a potential peek

although how that overlaps with SHC I'm not entirely sure

I think the best we can do for the moment is for villagers to keep reading and putting in work and we wait and see what WN does when it is no longer mrs. named's birthday. I feel like I should be able to clear him if he's a villager with a pretty high degree of confidence, plus he's one of my favourite people to work with.

The list you posted earlier Hardcore, I'm not saying you're a wolf, but it was a wolfy post in terms of construction and placement of players

sort of an example, you're probably clearing xkf too light, I made that mistake in the hobbit game, where he made some nice aggressive posts early and got consensus cleared early and then it turned out he was smaug and was being cleared because all the wolves knew him and felt it was important to clear him.

I thought well named was villagery after he started posting every day before now. He hasn't posted enough today, will see if he gives me any wolfy vibes later. I liked the way it seemed like he was trying to figure out my role d1. The more obviously villagery I became the more he started to go with me potentially being a villager. This was still at the point where it was looking like I was going to be lynched if a bunch of people didn't change their minds. It's not really a spot where a wolf should start saying I'm villagery if they are trying to actually lynch villagers. I wasn't pushing him at the time so it wasn't like he was trying to get me off his case or anything like he was doing in The Hobbitt.

Yeah, you get my problem, Binks. Astute posts.

Also like what Vix said and concur. I'm not willing to lynch Well named on both bases today. He's good enough to be a wolf here and certainly I thought he started badly, but to be honest, he's been much more villagey than, say, Chilltown or actually Hardcore. I mean, in the latter case, it's probably just that I feel uncomfortable when someone's hustling it along a bit much, and I've only ever seen him do that as a wolf.

hm, so were you a wolf in the hobbit game? not sure I'm understanding the thought process here.

I'm pretty sure he's saying he cleared Xkf too light in the Hobbit game and Xkf was a wolf there. Binkles was some sort of dwarf right?

yup

the smaug stuff isn't that important

also if my list is wrong in any way we can go through it. I can be wrong ldo, but I don't know how. like if the problem with my greens is xkf who seems to be at least partially SHCed and hasn't done much in the wolfy posts department, then I think people need to explain exactly why xkf can or is a wolf.

if chilltown is a wolf, huge props to him, but I don't see it. he tends to mail his wolf games in or at the very least be less active and rustled ITT.

also it doesn't seem like there is a lynch who isn't a potential seer or a potential peek. except for chilltown and xkf, who are pretty bad lynches today IMO.

if everyone has different peeks and we can't agree on a lynch then yeah, maybe claiming isn't quite so bad. or we can just lynch anarchist instead.

like I don't really know what to do. I don't wanna be tunneling, I just can't see the green people being wolves. I can be convinced otherwise, but it's not like anyone is doing anything to convince me otherwise.

and I have read and re-read this a fair amount.

I'd probably swap chilltown and xkf on that list is more what I meant I guess

everyone in seer contention except for rebonkulous has three live peeks.

everyone is married to their fakepeeks and the weekend is basically wasted here.

out of memory I think the peeks are:

me n0 binkles v, n1 well named w, n2 rebonkulous v
monkey n0 vix v, n1 rebonk v, n2 well named v
vix n0 xkf v, n1 monkey v, n2 someone wolf
rebonkulous n0 lkj v, n1 chill w, n2 vix v
annie I don't know the nights, but it's monkey/chilltown/vix, all v

there is no way we can lynch outside these claims heh

binkles, should the seer wait? do you see the problem here?

lemme think about it

and by that I mean lemme read and find the seer and get back to you :P

Yeah, I said "potential seers" though, not "everyone who is making a claim however ridiculous to be seer".

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSTONED.

wolves are NKing a bunch of people you think couldn't ever be seers

so yeah everyone is in seer contention no matter how ridiculous their peeks/claim are IMO

fwiw I didn't include wn because lol @ peeking me n1 heh

It would actually depend on who the seer is.

You should certainly include Well named. I think peeking you n1 would actually have been elite. You certainly can't dismiss his claim because of that, when you are supposed to have heropeeked a wolf lean and rebonk is supposed to have peeked LKJ on n0.

I guess the wolves have their reasons, Hardcore.

wn would never peek me cause he reads me super well or whatever

actually the reason I read you well is a level 2 reason to peek you. I can leave the peek and not have to worry about looking too seerish

also hai there

I'm not around for long just got back from dinner. Saw Les Mis. Really liked it.

I can see I didn't really miss much :P

should be "the fact that I read you well" hurp durp.