I think everyone is a villager to some degree or another except binkles/mets, who I am absolutely never clearing for those posts.

not clearing mets in this game is a pretty big leak

Why would the wolves both spazz out over me saying Anarchist made a significant slip if he was a wolf? Surely they would wonder (a) if it is true, or (b) if I peeked him. In neither case would they react like that itt. I don't think.

in before mets was a wolf and binkles is laughing his filthy wolfy ginger ass off at you tho

c) it wasn't an actual tarp and you just randomly caught two wolves :P

nahhhhhhhhhh

youre legit

amazingly.

I think anytime you find yourself thinking logically about "Why would a wolf do X" you should see giant flashing warning signs in your head

I could try reading Anarchist and judging by his own posts but that'll never work

still don't know wtf was that tarp.

like why would it ever work.

not that it didn't. it did.

it just shouldn't.

but that's my point, that's why "why would a wolf do X" is bad

wolves do stuff they shouldn't. I'm pretty sure that's why the game isn't completely random

is every other forum that plays werewolf just like a bunch of people that look like they're from 07 or something or am I just running really bad at choosing a good alternative?

wolves do chaotic crazy things

i'm pretty sure vix' trap just doesn't work if annie is a wolf tho

I think I prefer annie to MB as the lynch but it wouldn't shock me if MB were a wolf, given what I've read

no wai

:P

I have a possible theory, workin on it nao

What has he done that's really villagery? I don't really see it. I could have quoted more stuff so far but it was kind of boring, but that's what seems wolfy to me

you know I'll vote you tomorrow if annie flips villa right?

he has been ridiculously gamesolvey imo

and super aggro with everyone, which isn't what he does as a wolf. at least he says it. as a wolf he 'mullifies' people or something. I don't even know what it means, but it doesn't sound aggressive.

do what you gotta do. As a function of POE it's reasonable enough, but as a "if you're wrong you're a wolf" kind of thing it's a bad way to read people

But I'll just hope I'm not wrong :P

I only truly expect you to be right about mets 100% of the time.

and I trust that you are.

if it depended on me i'd probably go binkles > you > monkey and lose to annie or something :P

but you say mets is a villager, he is a villager and that's it.

but if you're wrong about annie, we can't really let you live because of d1. sounds too exploitative or something

i'm not sure that makes sense but OK :P

why are you clear?

i think clearing you would be elite but impossible for instance

Why am I not clear? I doubt there's any single thing I can point to and say that it means I'm 100% not a wolf, but I don't think I'm really wolfy. There are games where I manage to push a wolf in a way that people clear me for, or do wahtever, this just hasn't been one of them. I was wrong on d1, quite a bit, and had a bad day, that much is true, but it doesn't make me a wolf. I've had lots of village games like that over the years. Maybe the best reason why I'm clear is that I'm here trying, posting, wolf hunting, interacting, and being villagery. I don't really know what else there is. The biggest mechanical thing I know of that should be village points for me is just that you were not killed, but I understand that's not 100%. I think it should be possible to read me villager from my posts, even admitting I wasn't really on my best game d1

and on that note, I'm headed out from work. I probably won't be around much tonight, but I'll see you tomorrow.

I do it all the time in mishmashes, I never have done it in a vanilla until now. My reads are much better in mishmashes. Heh. Ok so this specific trap is I make an outrageous and blatantly false accusation at another player, wolves in an attempt to be villagery always take the easy bait and push the villager (me) making absurd posts. Or more like they don't even know how to react, they just start howling in response. It "catches" some villagers too here and there, but its way >>rand to nab some woofs. Psychologically the wolves are looking for things to talk about, and what better to talk about than a villager making a false accusation.

And typically I'd expect it to be a spot where they decided to white knight village Anarchist, that's usually what it means. The "reverse tmi" is a villager (me) makes a false accusation (that someone slipped, again given it is false this usually means the player is a villager) and then the wolves are all "lolwat there is no slip" because they know there isn't one; because they have tmi.

When you see any sequence that goes

player A: "this post has tmi"
player B: "no it doesn't"

And player B is not responding to an accusation against himself, this is always >rand statement coming from a wolf due to reverse tmi.