Quote:
Originally Posted by ihcjay
If I can talk to Gad and confirm in private what his role is then we can figure out if my other info is correct or not.
Remember at least one of my "peeks" is correct but they both might be which would be huge
wat
then where is the value in whispering to me?
we whisper, i say "i'm a baker," you say "cool! that's what my gossip info says you are!" and that tells you what, exactly, about the other info you have
contrariwise, from your perspective:
we whisper, i'm a lying wolf and say "i'm a candlestick maker," you say "ah, my info for you is different...that means my other info must be correct"?
that doesn't work either
like, unless i'm missing something, you have no basis to draw conclusions about the other role if:
a) i tell the truth and it matches the info you have
b) i tell the truth and it doesn't match the info you have
c) i lie and it matches the info you have
d) i lie and it doesn't match the info you have
other than c) being statistically unlikely, how will whispering help you divine, first, whether i'm telling the truth about my role and, second, what that means for the other role you have info about?
forgive me if i'm being dumb