Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD) ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)

05-05-2009 , 06:51 AM
@ jobeen

You see if we wagon other people today and mis-lynch a villager (most likely considering how we are batting) then we KNOW FOR SURE that the mis-lynched villager was a villager.

Heaps more information than killing corsakh will bring.
05-05-2009 , 06:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cardassian ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)
@ jobeen
you have to watch tomorrows wagon closely. whoever votes cors is most probably a wolf.
05-05-2009 , 06:53 AM
I don't care at the moment what you guys think about killing cors it's not as if youv'e started any goddamm wagons today anyway.
the guy claims seer and causes us to mislynch a villager and we are going to allow him to live. (sorry mrs buttons) on the off chance that he's not a wolf don't care there's no infomation he can give that we can trust any more i say kill him
05-05-2009 , 06:54 AM
This village can not even lynch a seer picked, lolcat posting, wolf chat talking pup.
This is pathetic.
05-05-2009 , 06:56 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jobeen ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)
I don't care at the moment what you guys think about killing cors it's not as if youv'e started any goddamm wagons today anyway.
the guy claims seer and causes us to mislynch a villager and we are going to allow him to live. (sorry mrs buttons) on the off chance that he's not a wolf don't care there's no infomation he can give that we can trust any more i say kill him
srsly, you can't be this dumb? i mean - look at his goddam last two dozen posts. cors has already started spewing the other wolves in secret morse code. once we hack the code = village win.

that is why we can't lynch cors.
05-05-2009 , 07:06 AM
Female fail. Dont defend too hard people might realise you are wolfeee.
05-05-2009 , 07:07 AM
go figure it out then im doing what i said i would
cos i think when you find a wolf you kill it
and all those people that said if cos isn't nk we can lynch him today where the hell have you all gone?
to the library to do more research?
give me a break!
05-05-2009 , 07:16 AM
jobeen wagon

unless she posts pics ldo
05-05-2009 , 07:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by goofyballer ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)
jobeen wagon

unless she posts pics ldo
fyp

jobeen
05-05-2009 , 08:09 AM
OK, I am back in the land of the consistent internets. and...

WTF is going on here? I actually cant tell who is leveling, who isnt, blah blah meow chow.

Quick first thoughts are that Cors has to go, and might as well be voted by majority cuz:
1) We arent learning anything else today, people who say we will havent read the last 200+ posts with basically zeron content.
2) Thw wolf-hunting this village has done so far has been awesome eh? If it wasnt for the SK, this would be over.
3) Spamming the thread with lolcats is cool, morse code hurts my eyes, i forgot how to translate that sheet 20 years ago.

Does anyone have an updated vote count? I wouldnt mind seeing a majority and move on to a new day.
05-05-2009 , 09:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by djstu ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)
I agree with brian that ilya is a good wagon for today.

Also, I think now would be a good time to talk strategy about dealing with WER here. Mainly if we should kill him or let the wolves do it. I'll think about it tonight.
I'd say it's about 33/33/33 on WER being villa/SK/wolf. 33% is hudge for overall percent chance he's SK though. I think it's very likely that at this point SK starts collaborating with wolves so that villa doesn't pull too far ahead, assuming we've got 2 wolves out of Ilya/corsakh/jumanji. So we've got to stop the bleeding before it starts. That said, SK seems perfectly content to wolfhunt atm, and only strayed when cardassian threatened to out him.

I say we give WER another night and see what he does - if we lynch for an SK and wind up being wrong, we could really fux ourselves.

I'm not really sure how to SK hunt either. I think WER has a good strategy for SK - with his high post count, he isn't likely to peeked, which AFAIK SK doesn't want to be peeked. I think there's virtually no way that an SK wins if he is peeked. Either wolves will kill him off before finals, or all wolves will be dead so villagers will lynch confirmed peeks.

I also don't think he's made any effort to leave fake peeks, which an SK wouldn't want to leave obviously. WER, pls link to your fakepeeks if you've left them. IIRC there was something about cardassian but that's it.

I def think WER should be a wagon today regardless though.
05-05-2009 , 10:02 AM
Actually, scratch that part about Dolly. Too much fps imo.
05-05-2009 , 10:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by nightwood ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)
winnaarrrrrrrrr. omg this is so brilliant

unvote
:facepalm:

If corsakh doesn't die today I'm quitting WW. Lets maj him at 12 so we get another day . Sakh
05-05-2009 , 10:17 AM
Surprised no one has done a reread of cors yet - he's def the type to spew people villa, maybe even a wolf. I'm almost certainly dying tonight, especially if we don't get the SK, so I'll do it later this afternoon if no one else has. and get some final thoughts out before EOD.

unvote
vote WinEvryRacex
05-05-2009 , 10:18 AM
Brian, Sakh is not going to spew now that we know he is a wolf.
05-05-2009 , 10:19 AM
BitchieBee I approve of your new avatar.
05-05-2009 , 10:19 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BitchiBee ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)
:facepalm:

If corsakh doesn't die today I'm quitting WW. Lets maj him at 12 so we get another day . Sakh
That's a horrible and pro-wolf idea. We'll have two people dying tonight, so if you majority before they get to the thread, they might not even get to post their last thoughts.

We also should use the entire day to do some rereads of people. Seriously, majoritying is bad for the village 9 times out of 10; this is not a special case.
05-05-2009 , 10:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BitchiBee ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)
Brian, Sakh is not going to spew now that we know he is a wolf.
I never said he was.

If you guys want to lynch him tonight then fine, but majoritying would be horribad.
05-05-2009 , 10:22 AM
unvote
05-05-2009 , 10:43 AM
lol at the overnight developments, I don't see how doing anything but killing corsakh today is right
05-05-2009 , 10:44 AM
Brian are you being serious? Just wondering if you are trying to level us into voting for someone else or something.
05-05-2009 , 11:43 AM
Let's talk about the SK for a minute here.

The Serial Killer wants the Seers alive as long as possible. Especially to the point where they are peeked villager. An even more ideal time, would be when a seer comes out and expressly says "These are my Picks: N1: xxxx N2: xxxx" etc... so that we don't have to try and interpret Dead Seers peeks in past posts.

Both Seers already being dead is bad for the SK. because now that means they have most likely not been peeked. The SK wants the Seers to peek them villager. Preferably with as many other peeked villagers still alive as possible. Because with the Seers dead, the Wolves will probably start NKing all of the confirmed, peeked villagers. So we don't really need to worry about Peeked villagers right now (Who do we think all of the peeked villagers are anyways? Brian? Goofy? BitchiBee?)
05-05-2009 , 11:50 AM
Also, I am in favor of lynching Corsakh as soon as possible.

We are not going to learn anything else from him. he is never going to vote anymore, because he doesn't want to give away any information.

So, lets Major Vote Corsakh. And then Mr SK: Please be NKing Ilya. Thanks.
05-05-2009 , 12:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by I_Like_Beer ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)
Let's talk about the SK for a minute here.

The Serial Killer wants the Seers alive as long as possible. Especially to the point where they are peeked villager. An even more ideal time, would be when a seer comes out and expressly says "These are my Picks: N1: xxxx N2: xxxx" etc... so that we don't have to try and interpret Dead Seers peeks in past posts.

Both Seers already being dead is bad for the SK. because now that means they have most likely not been peeked. The SK wants the Seers to peek them villager. Preferably with as many other peeked villagers still alive as possible. Because with the Seers dead, the Wolves will probably start NKing all of the confirmed, peeked villagers. So we don't really need to worry about Peeked villagers right now (Who do we think all of the peeked villagers are anyways? Brian? Goofy? BitchiBee?)
I disagree. See my posts about SK throughout the thread (one earlier today RE:WER being SK) for my take on SK strategy.

Cliff's notes: I think there is virtually no way for SK to win if he is seer-peeked.
05-05-2009 , 12:46 PM
Ok, I made it through the thread, post D1, to do seer peeking and as everyone else has said, I can see the peeks for Goofy and BB villa, maybe Brian, and Cors as a wolf, but not a single one would I consider 100% locked clear.

I originally thought that Ilya was a wolf peek by Bingo, but then the next day he turns around and doesnt like his thoughts anymore, could Ilya actually have been a villa peek?

I think we obv need to continue on today towards the Corsahk lynch, but at this point, we wont have a second day, so might as well use the rest of today/tonite to talk/post/analyze.

As for the SK discussion, I think both Brian and Beer have good points. IMO the SK would never want to seer hunt, he wants to be peeked, along with a multitude of other villagers. He wants the seers to remain hidden, while at the same time have the wolves seer-hunting unsuccessfully.

At this point of the game, with both seers gone, IF he did get peeked, he will be a wolf NK, and I dont really think we need to concern ourselves with it. If he has not been peeked, well we will need to try and find a pattern with the NK's, which I am relatively confident will arise as the days progress.

just my thoughts after reading this travesty of a thread

      
m