ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD) - Page 26 - Puzzles and Other Games Forum

Huh? I did not say that. I said I thought you might have some insight into the reasons he might have been killed, you had more experience playing with him than any one else here. Everything happens for a reason, something must have triggered his death.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:14 AM

#627

mburke05

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 11,928

why karak bryan?

and @ cardassian, i spent about 2 pages of reasoning for voting goofy on days 3-6 so you'll have to elaborate when you specify which of my reasoning for voting him wasn't logical. granted day 1-2 were readless, but it was my first game and i thought it was suspicious that a mod who posts as often as he does in the SSNLife thread would be UTR in a big game.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:15 AM

#628

cardassian

old hand

Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 1,510

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brian

I'm gonna post a review of all 3 dead players in a minute, but first to continue the Star Trek discussion: ST: Enterprise is so good Season 3-4, esp 4.

Yeah seasons 3&4 were wicked.
Really thought the first season was weak tho.
There was that character that after a whole season all you really knew about him is he liked pineapple and he was one of the main characters.
But it definately turned into a good series.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:16 AM

#629

corsakh

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 12,149

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardassian

lol. I looked into this and yeah it's true.

mburke voted for goofy every day and goofy was a wolf.

However to be fair mburke didn't use a lot of reasoning the first couple of days in regards to it.

Could be a sick read (like felix has on me) or it could be that mburke just likes voting goofy, guess we'll have to wait and see.

The part that I found interesting about it is that it seemed to put goofy on a little tilt at the end (or maybe he was joking, I don't know).

Quote:

Originally Posted by goofyballer

I'm never playing ww with you idiots again.

"lol vote for the guy who mods our forum"

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:16 AM

#630

Slink

centurion

Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 192

Im off to bed and will be back four hours before nightfall. For now I am going to

vote Malgin

for the fishy way he turned up late last night - like he was watching and just voting when he had to - trying to stay UTR.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:17 AM

#631

cardassian

old hand

Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 1,510

Quote:

Originally Posted by mburke05

Dude all your reasoning was logical. I was just saying the first couple of days there was no reasoning. As you say it was readless.

But then you came in with sound logic (d3 or d4 i think) and made a strong case, stuck to it and was right.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:21 AM

#632

Brian.

banned

Join Date: Aug 2003 Posts: 5,676

Kesh wolfspewed so many villas it's not even funny. He also had some interactions with djstu that seem w/w to me, and there's this between him and gtpitch:

Quote:

Originally Posted by gtpitch

Quote:

Originally Posted by keshaldra

Wolves going back and forth to put on a show, imo.

Kesh basically nailed it with this one. Almost seems that way. The only problem is that I don't think they have had the first wolf chat yet.. or have they?

Going with WU

Quote:

Originally Posted by keshaldra

uhh....159nd?

o hai everyone. Village ldo here, and not seeing one of Wraths' crazy posts makes me suspicious...

Well we know WU is villa now so don't learn anything here.

Quote:

Originally Posted by keshaldra

I think the concern is that TOO MUCH cover confuses the rest of the villagers, making it difficult to determine who the REAL seer's peeks are. I'm not exactly a pro-level villager, and it's difficult for me to tell sometimes.

Urges villagers not to leave seer cover; and his reason is lol. Makes it difficult for the wolves to determine who the real seer's peeks are, oh noes!

Quote:

Originally Posted by keshaldra

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wraths Unanimous

LOL someone please tell me that is not the most wolfy post you have ever read. I mean COME ONNNNNN!

Wolves going back and forth to put on a show, imo.

mdom is villa.

In response to djstu questioning stark:

Quote:

Originally Posted by keshaldra

This.

Doesn't feel like stark's style and is giving me a bit of a wolf lean.

stark is villa.

Quote:

Originally Posted by keshaldra

I didn't mean offense or anything, I'm just saying that this is different from your normal style...I'd never seen you just pick out an impromptu list like that before. Different styles = different roles imo.

Stark is villa.

Quote:

Originally Posted by keshaldra

Wolf lists = wolf. Despite voting for Wraths, I'm down for an Ilikebeer/stark wagon.

ILB (calling you that for sure from now on btw) is villa.

Quote:

Originally Posted by keshaldra

Ok, this is EXTRA wolfy to me. I didn't want to read too much into the "zomg, I'm a villager again" post, as I'm known to do the same thing myself...but ILB's pushing it a little too far imo.

ILB villa.

Quote:

Originally Posted by keshaldra

Me too, but man, that looks bad on his part.

ILB villa.

BTW, would like to add that other Brian is my villa brother. Brian's 4L I'll never vote u <3.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:24 AM

#633

Mrsbutton

Pooh-Bah

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 4,864

Quote:

Originally Posted by WinEvryRacex

It's looking like v-v wagons to me, so unfortunately our wagons sucked.

Would have been nice to have a THIRD wagon for comparison.

i tried to get 2 third wagons going but no on wanted to listen to me

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:24 AM

#634

jobeen

centurion

Join Date: Apr 2009 Posts: 169

ok just reread jumanji's posts and i could be a little suspicious of him cos he may have hurt my feelings a bit in his (#301) post. i'll try to forgive him.....

ok i forgive him

back to the drawing board

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:27 AM

#635

Brian.

banned

Join Date: Aug 2003 Posts: 5,676

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardassian

Mayweather was basically an extra, and a bad one at that. Hoshi was meh. I've got a hardon for Bakula tho

and Phlox/T'Pol/Trip were all well-acted. When they handed the writing over to Manny Coto (did 24 back when it was still good) and Braga/Berman monstrosity got out of the way, the show was allowed to shine.

Also, so many people rip Enterprise for bad early seasons, but try rewatching TNG Season 1, or TOS, or any of Voyager.

BTW we'll take the nerd convention out of thread now but these things had to be said.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:29 AM

#636

Mrsbutton

Pooh-Bah

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 4,864

Quote:

Originally Posted by corsakh

I figure I need to address this since a couple people pointed out.

The thing is, d0 voting is mostly a crapshoot anyway, with a lot of early villa on villa violence. Early AFK wagons help us to avoid lynching helpful and active villas, who just happened to get off the wrong foot at the start. In addition to this, if an AFK survives the lynch and sees it, it may give him incentive to participate more actively in the game. And a signal to the others. Worst case scenario, we just get rid of dead weight. Also note that a lot wolves in rookie games like to start UTR. And a lot of d0 lynches, and probably most, are misslycnhes anyway. Sure, d0 lynches may give some info in the future. But I am not sure how much and I feel that wagons on d0 may give just as much in the long run. More exp players please correct me if I wrong here.

UTR and AFK are two different things in a day or so we can do after the UTR because we will know the people who arent here will get subbed waht is our seer isnt even playing yet and we lynch him cause he is AFK makes no sence to me

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:29 AM

#637

Brian.

banned

Join Date: Aug 2003 Posts: 5,676

BTW I think this was mentioned, but someone must have killed dnky because they thought he was a strong player. Probably whoever the wolfpack leader is has played a lot of turbos with him. Anyone know who this could be?

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:33 AM

#638

corsakh

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 12,149

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brian

corsakh probably has to go at some point; guarantee you'll all think he's a wolf at one time or another, but in general he spreads mass confusion and bad ideas. He's already started in this game by suggesting we lynch an AFK Day 1. I have a villa lean on him for now but dude, pls not be tarding up this game.

Sigh, this is dirty. You know that the only way for me to answer this would involve me discussing an ongoing game and that I can not do. So I don't know what you are trying to achieve by saying this.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:35 AM

#639

jobeen

centurion

Join Date: Apr 2009 Posts: 169

through the mirror darkly season 4, was wicked

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:36 AM

#640

Brian.

banned

Join Date: Aug 2003 Posts: 5,676

@ Karak: He doesn't like that I'm coming after him and Win on D1, and says we shouldn't be lynching experienced villies Day 1 (and puts himself in that group):

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karak567

also, even if they are wolfy, please don't lynch any experienced players on d1. very silly.

Then pushes experienced players later:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karak567

For what it's worth, I think Brian and Beer wagons (haha i said BEER WAGON) are solid today.

beer

I also don't think Beer was spewing wolf at all yesterday, but I have past experience w him.

In reference to JackFrost:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karak567

not clearing him at all, but this is very standard play for him

also earlier in the thread dnky said he spews wolf a lot, even when he is a villager. again, not clearing him, but this is true.

This sort of wishy-washiness lets him reneg on JF without being inconsistent.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:38 AM

#641

corsakh

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 12,149

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brian

FYP

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:39 AM

#642

Mrsbutton

Pooh-Bah

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 4,864

Quote:

Originally Posted by BingoBango

Firstly, I'd like to apologize for my lolbad vote yesterday. I had a slight inclination towards WU being a villa so I voted for beer. But no justified reason for voting beer. And I see why voting beer with the reason I stated is pretty bad. I don't think hes a wolf at this point, mostly because of what the keshaldra killing tells us. I'll also point out that, if I'm a wolf, that vote would have been suicidal and I would like to think I would make a better wolf than that. But I have not been one yet.

Secondly of all, I think BB brings up a good point. I also read Soah's strat guide about the secondary wolf thing. However, at that point, stark had already gained some attention from posting that list of his. Assuming stark is a wolf, wouldn't pushing that wagon be a little reckless at that point of the game? If stark gets some spite votes out of that list, kesh would have been in a pretty ****ty spot

way to repeat what was just said above you
BingoBango

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:39 AM

#643

Brian.

banned

Join Date: Aug 2003 Posts: 5,676

I'll be AFK starting early this afternoon, music fest here in Memphis. Going to see All-American Rejects, and unfortunately I'm not a 14 y/o girl and I don't cut myself, so I really have no excuse.

So placing my vote on

vote Karak567

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:40 AM

#644

Brian.

banned

Join Date: Aug 2003 Posts: 5,676

Quote:

Originally Posted by corsakh

FYP

I'll admit I can't use a search button so I see you've volunteered for this job? Tyvm!

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:43 AM

#645

corsakh

Carpal \'Tunnel

Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 12,149

Then how many trubos have you played with dnky?

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:52 AM

#646

cardassian

old hand

Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 1,510

Quote:

Originally Posted by corsakh

Then how many trubos have you played with dnky?

I've played a few with him. In fact in my first turbo i wolfed with him and he tried busing me d1 (13 man game) I ended up starting a wagon on him d3 and getting him lynched. McAvoy voted him 2nd (my wolf partner) and we refrained from nking felix (he was the best villa left at this stage) as we thought McAvoy had already levelled him into believing he was villa. We were right and won comfortably. Ever since then felix has soul read me.

I also played a long game with dnky where we were both seers. he came out d2 but the wolves didn't believe him, unfortunately i got my wires crossed and came out d4 and fracked it up for the village.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:56 AM

#647

gtpitch

making sick bumps

Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 33,706

Quote:

Originally Posted by corsakh

Then how many trubos have you played with dnky?

I've played quite a few with him I know that

Off the top of my head so has:

Nightwood
buttons
karak

I'm sure I'm missing someone but there ya go so far.

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:58 AM

#648

jobeen

centurion

Join Date: Apr 2009 Posts: 169

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slink

um whats with this post it's only his third in the entire thread and he votes on the malgins utr play?

Quote

05-01-2009 , 09:58 AM

#649

gtpitch

making sick bumps

Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 33,706

Quote:

Originally Posted by gtpitch

I've played quite a few with him I know that

Off the top of my head so has:

Nightwood
buttons
karak

I'm sure I'm missing someone but there ya go so far.

Remembered Caedus is subbing in also who has played a lot of turbos with him.