imo, fluff is the order of the day d1. im not gonna call out gt for all of those posts.

however, i dont at all like this post:

Originally Posted by gtpitch View Post
Everyone please to keep this post in mind if\when (?) mdom comes up wolf.

this post alone is enought to garner a vote gtpitch

Wolf lists = wolf. Despite voting for Wraths, I'm down for an Ilikebeer/stark wagon.

last part is a flat out lie, also usually don't you chime in earlier with something? zzzzz

beer for now

sigh

this is true imo. this is either bad villager move d1 or a wolf playing with perfect information.

either way, i dont like this.

Neither slink or chaser has posted yet.

Why the hell are people putting people with zero posts on their wolf lists? I'm all for UTR players being suspicious in the long run but you can't possibly have a read on somebody who hasn't said anything yet. The "to see their response" explanation is weak imo, especially when you consider that only the supremely dumb wolves will give you the reactions you're looking for. And the supremely dumb wolves are gonna out themselves anyway, so it's completely pointless. The only reason to do it is to make it look like you're trying extra hard to find wolves when it's you really aren't.

Plus the "BTW I'm a villager " line reeks of wolf. I don't want to appear to be going down on kesh but an ILB/stark wagon looks pretty good to me right now.

ZOMGBBQ I played 1 game! I'm sorry for being rational

That's cool if you all want to vote me out today. That way I can then get subbed back in as something more interesting than villager.

Vote Beer for the Win!

BTW, when is end of day one? in 3.5 hours or 27.5 hours?

a bit over 3 hours, and half the people ITT havent even posted yet.

fail.

9PM EST tonight ILB.

and seriously if you have an explanation give it. Not defending yourself is stupid if you are a villager, it practically makes us have to lynch you just to figure out your role.

A wolf needs something to say, a villa wouldn't need to post that. But I'll let it slide as this is your 2nd game and most newbies come off wolfy, I'll be keeping my eye on you though .

Why would you say this as villager? :facepalm:

Hopefully because he also does this as a leveling seer.

vote ILB for now, I'll revisit if he starts acting villagery again but those last 2 posts of his are just utterly terrible.

Ok, this is EXTRA wolfy to me. I didn't want to read too much into the "zomg, I'm a villager again" post, as I'm known to do the same thing myself...but ILB's pushing it a little too far imo.

so he's giving himself a death warrant? I can't see how a villager would not defend themselves, and if he claims seer before EOD he's just gonna get nked by the wolves on the off chance that he actually is that bad.

Meh, I kinda believe him.

basing anything off of what people said on day 1 is dumb. Think back to all the other games you have played. Now think back to the number of times you revisted anything from D1 later on in the game. That number is zero, isn't it?

Na, I'd say most of the wolves haven't even posted ITT yet. Why bring attention to yourself on D1 when everything is pretty much random in D1 voting, right?

Oops, I was referring to this part.

Me too, but man, that looks bad on his part.

And please, Call me either I_Like_Beer or Beer. ILB sounds dumb.

[0] A.Ertbjerg
[0] Ainex
[0] BingoBango
[0] BitchiBee
[0] Brian -mdom88
[0] cardassian -mburke05
[0] chaser1942
[0] corsakh -starkwired
[0] djstu -beer
[0] dnkyhunter31 -gtpitch
[1] goofyballer
[2] gtpitch
[0] Hardball47
[2] I_Like_Beer
[0] IlyaMuromec
[0] Jack Frost -jumangiboard
[0] jobeen
[1] JumanjiBoard
[0] Karak567
[0] keshaldra -Wraths Unanimous
[0] Malgin
[1] mburke05
[2] mdom88 -goofyballer
[0] Mrsbutton
[0] nightwood
[0] O0Brian0O-gtpitch
[0] RiverFenix
[0] saymond
[0] Slink
[1] starkwired - beer
[0] WinEvryRacex
[1] Wraths Unanimous -mdom88

Wait, do we have 3 mods? (OTI, JD, ewalsh)?

Reads have to start somewhere. Reads off 1-3 posts aren't strong at all, but people that post a lot, even on d1, help in reading them a lot.

Like rene in our last game.

I agree generally, but both you and stark claiming wolf reads on people who haven't posted makes utterly no sense if you are villagers. There's no real point to it except to pad your wolf lists and make it look like you're hunting wolves more than you are. No villager does that, wolves do.

So, give me a good reason beyond "I wanted to see their reactions", and I'll take my vote off of you.

Btw, I also like the 3 wagon idea for the first several days. We should be trying to make 3 decent wagons today.