Slink reread:
First I went through and checked out some of his posts from the SSNL game we played where he was villa, but fairly UTR (34 posts all game). The Slink from that game was confident and assertive with his reads, did lots of analysis, and was borderline reckless with his voting (he voted for lots of villas but never second-guessed himself). Examples:
722: thorough analysis on another villa who was up for lynching, correctly defends him
1072: tons of analysis on large # of players
1079: calls out a villa for disagreeing with his logic
1090: one of the few posts where he asks questions, but he only does so in an accusatory manner in making a case against someone (i.e. "why would you do this if you weren't a wolf?")
1102,
1257,
1349,
1354 - just examples of posts displaying his confident attitude where he doesn't really rely on others
In this game:
603: lots of early analysis, villa list includes corsakh/nightwood/unknowns, wolf list includes bingobango/WER/malgin/djstu/mrsbutton. hard to gain info on d2, don't think we should read too much into his reads being bad. style is similar to ssnl game.
Later makes these two posts:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slink
Malgin can you please post a list saying who you think is wolfy/ villagery and why.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slink
A.Ertbjerg please also let us know your wolf list asap.
I don't think I ever saw him ask other people for their reads in the SSNL game. I feel like asking others for wolf lists is something I see wolves do a lot.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slink
WOW. Nice result serial killer. We must buy you a beer.
I would like to ask again for the following guys to give me their thoughts on who is wolfy and villa like:
chaser
malgin
a.ertjberg
Illya
Whoever out of this quad contributes the least ITT will get my vote in 5 hours time and I will try to drum up other customers against them.
Again, this is something I NEVER saw him do as a villa in the SSNL game. This change of strategies (going from largely making his own reads to asking other people for his, shifting attention onto others all the time) is super suspicious.
1199: lots of analysis, tries to start A.E wagon, similar posting style as SSNL game. Leaned villa on RF but had ok reason for doing so, leaned villa on nightwood, leaned wolfy on mburke, good reads (which is unusual for him early on
but I won't fault him for that)
1605: identifies cardassian putting heat on mburke as a possible reason for wolves NKing him, says that mburke wagon isn't bad - big villa points imo (with the one exception that this post is a lot easier to make if you know mburke is a wolf, but I don't think it's likely slink would go out on a limb like this as a wolf just b/c he has mostly distanced himself from other wolves throughout the game so far)
1620: again pushes the idea that card was the wolves' NK and that it was because of mburke.
Lots of posts between then and the corsakh cluster**** that I'm having a hard time reading but am getting a villa-ish lean from.
2237: Thinks corsakh cleared nightwood as villa, ++villa points, points out jobeen is looking wolfy from corsakh posts.
2428: defends nightwood again. leaning villa here since after the nightwood lynching, a bad wolf would be like "look guys I defended the guy we lynched!!!", but slink hasn't brought it up, which I think is very villa of him. if he's a wolf, I think he's playing a pretty ****ing good one.
I think I've mostly seen enough so I'll just skip to the important-ish posts that are left:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slink
You better go back inactive if you are going to start posting like that!
I think it was Ainex who did a big review of me early on and didnt find anything. Look through his posts. If you want to take up the challenge against me I am more than happy to answer any questions. I have nothing to hide in this game as I am a sure fire villager.
This feels like something he would have posted in the SSNL game
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slink
Hey 00Brian I have missed you. Welcome back.
Who are your top 3 wolves at the moment mate?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slink
I think if you actually went back and read 2500 posts you would be clearing them too. No hard feelings JD. Do what you got to do. While you at it give me your thoughts on your top 3 wolves as well.
These two posts worry me a little, as like I've said, the "ask other ppl for their wolf lists" is not a move that was in his arsenal during the SSNL game. But, the weight of the evidence still points villa.
And now that I've gone and done all this research...
Quote:
Originally Posted by starkwired
The only significant interaction from yesterday (I did a quick run through, might have missed something) is with Slink, who has been playing differently than the last game when he was villa anyway.
Can you explain this, since I'm not seeing it? To be fair though you prob have a different perspective on it than I do since you were on his team in that game and I, well, wasn't