ROOKIE GAME THREAD!!! (9:30 pm EOD)
05-07-2009
, 12:52 AM
05-07-2009
, 12:56 AM
05-07-2009
, 01:05 AM
05-07-2009
, 01:07 AM
05-07-2009
, 01:12 AM
05-07-2009
, 01:14 AM
05-07-2009
, 01:15 AM
05-07-2009
, 01:21 AM
05-07-2009
, 01:23 AM
OK I thought I would beat J.D. to it and summarise his posts in the game so far for the villages sake.
Firstly, before he is even playing the game, he starts out as a "co-mod" with OTI. In this role, what do you think the chances are that he knows what the roles are? Prob its not much of a chance at all but I'm just putting it out there.
Then we look at Saymonds posts, which are all fluff except for this one, his last:
This quote is a bizarre one. Tbh, I think it would be the other way around. If you didnt have the time to do wolf chat properly in the evenings you would be a hindrance to the wolf team so you may as well sub yourself out. If you are a villager, you wouldn't give as much of a cra p as it didnt matter as much.
So Saymond gets replaced and J.D. takes over:
Beer has proven to be pretty solid villager imo and has been cleared by seers from memory. So bad vote but maybe he can be excused for it as he is just starting.
Next: Spends a lot of time promising to be active but never living up to his promise. A couple of days later he turns up again.
Reasonable comments here.
Fair enough.
And then he starts on me. 
Anyway just thought I would summarise for the villages sake. Not much to go on past Saymond's first post but I think J.D. I getting away with a lot by not posting so lets not forget about him. Next I will look into other players opinions of him in the game and how that may mean anything. Not having a go J.D., just summarising for the sake of the village.
Firstly, before he is even playing the game, he starts out as a "co-mod" with OTI. In this role, what do you think the chances are that he knows what the roles are? Prob its not much of a chance at all but I'm just putting it out there.
Then we look at Saymonds posts, which are all fluff except for this one, his last:
So Saymond gets replaced and J.D. takes over:
Quote:
I am here! and as Saymond said, obviously villa. I have read most of the thread and the one thing that stuck out to me is
I_Like_Beer He flat out lied about his role in a previous game. Someone called him out on it, but never went further than that, doesnt seem like something a villager would do.
I_Like_Beer He flat out lied about his role in a previous game. Someone called him out on it, but never went further than that, doesnt seem like something a villager would do.
Next: Spends a lot of time promising to be active but never living up to his promise. A couple of days later he turns up again.
Quote:
Ok, I made it through the thread, post D1, to do seer peeking and as everyone else has said, I can see the peeks for Goofy and BB villa, maybe Brian, and Cors as a wolf, but not a single one would I consider 100% locked clear.
I originally thought that Ilya was a wolf peek by Bingo, but then the next day he turns around and doesnt like his thoughts anymore, could Ilya actually have been a villa peek?
I think we obv need to continue on today towards the Corsahk lynch, but at this point, we wont have a second day, so might as well use the rest of today/tonite to talk/post/analyze.
As for the SK discussion, I think both Brian and Beer have good points. IMO the SK would never want to seer hunt, he wants to be peeked, along with a multitude of other villagers. He wants the seers to remain hidden, while at the same time have the wolves seer-hunting unsuccessfully.
At this point of the game, with both seers gone, IF he did get peeked, he will be a wolf NK, and I dont really think we need to concern ourselves with it. If he has not been peeked, well we will need to try and find a pattern with the NK's, which I am relatively confident will arise as the days progress.
just my thoughts after reading this travesty of a thread
I originally thought that Ilya was a wolf peek by Bingo, but then the next day he turns around and doesnt like his thoughts anymore, could Ilya actually have been a villa peek?
I think we obv need to continue on today towards the Corsahk lynch, but at this point, we wont have a second day, so might as well use the rest of today/tonite to talk/post/analyze.
As for the SK discussion, I think both Brian and Beer have good points. IMO the SK would never want to seer hunt, he wants to be peeked, along with a multitude of other villagers. He wants the seers to remain hidden, while at the same time have the wolves seer-hunting unsuccessfully.
At this point of the game, with both seers gone, IF he did get peeked, he will be a wolf NK, and I dont really think we need to concern ourselves with it. If he has not been peeked, well we will need to try and find a pattern with the NK's, which I am relatively confident will arise as the days progress.
just my thoughts after reading this travesty of a thread
Quote:
Hi Village! This is the first night I have had a chance to actually follow it live. Seems very low volume today also.
I still like the Danny wagon, although he hasnt done much to defend himself, which scares me with only 2 wolves left. They need to be fighting tooth and nail right now. (pun intended, cue Goofy facepalm)
Worst case he mislynch, but it helps clear up the peek situation, which is anything BUT clear right now.
I also have been trying to figure out what the best way to find who the SK is, but I just dont think we can, if we post about a pattern, he will simply switch it up. One thing should be clear though, the wolves absolutely do not want him killed, they need a couple nights of 2 villa kills to get back into this.
Also, one name I have not heard brought up yet at all is Slink, why is that? Have I missed him being cleared somewhere (yes, its quite possible). If I did, cliffs please? I think he seems wolfy at times on tone, and his voting record sucks.
I should be more active from here on out, so lets do this.
I still like the Danny wagon, although he hasnt done much to defend himself, which scares me with only 2 wolves left. They need to be fighting tooth and nail right now. (pun intended, cue Goofy facepalm)
Worst case he mislynch, but it helps clear up the peek situation, which is anything BUT clear right now.
I also have been trying to figure out what the best way to find who the SK is, but I just dont think we can, if we post about a pattern, he will simply switch it up. One thing should be clear though, the wolves absolutely do not want him killed, they need a couple nights of 2 villa kills to get back into this.
Also, one name I have not heard brought up yet at all is Slink, why is that? Have I missed him being cleared somewhere (yes, its quite possible). If I did, cliffs please? I think he seems wolfy at times on tone, and his voting record sucks.
I should be more active from here on out, so lets do this.
Anyway just thought I would summarise for the villages sake. Not much to go on past Saymond's first post but I think J.D. I getting away with a lot by not posting so lets not forget about him. Next I will look into other players opinions of him in the game and how that may mean anything. Not having a go J.D., just summarising for the sake of the village.
05-07-2009
, 01:25 AM
05-07-2009
, 01:29 AM
05-07-2009
, 01:33 AM