Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
I'll give a couple thoughts on some of the players slink mentioned
ily - He has posted 3 times:
"RiverFenix seems to make the most sense and I don't have much of an idea of what I'm doing, so I'll tag along with what he says
Malgin
Quote:
this mirrors my trail of thought. That and I'm effin clueless :P
Quote:
my god, I've read through 675 posts and am still clueless o_O.
I do recall a few avatars n stuff. So given that I've never played this before, I'll be pretty useless, I'm sorry in advance.
Now, do people pull up an excel sheet and put their reads etc in there or how do people keep track? Also, what's the relevance of the post counts being posted here a while earlier?
Also, just reading through basic villager strategy:
Quote:
It's hard to keep track of who said what in there. Other villagers will see 100 posts since they last checked the thread, and just give up. If they bother with the thread at all, it's to hop to the end, and they vote for whoever looks like a likely target.
It is very daunting to read through 670 posts, where maybe 100 were of any real value. I don't know how these games are usually run but I don't want to spend my days sifting through haystacks, looking for a couple of needles Just my 2 cent observation. "
This looks pretty wolfy. No content, making excuses about being a noob. Not voting d1 seems like something a noob wolf would do. He also voted Malgin for no clear reason. I don't like the late vote and I don't like the logic behind it.
Now if you look at the posts that Bingo was suspicious of, you can see that they are relatively consistent. I dont think a wolf just comes out and says these things. Although it appears he isnt helping the village much by admittedly just tagging along, I think the tone of these posts is more of honesty than of deception. The fact that the player who brought these posts up ended up a seer doesn not necessarily damm Ilya, as seer's are trying to uncover wolves by organic means along with their special power. If/when I am seer I do my best to leave subtle peeks but also am trying to make normal reads on players I havnt peeked, as it is +EV for the village.
It is my conclusion that the seer DID NOT peek ilya at any point, was making an honest read, but was mistaken. Ilya CLEARLY does NOT look like a wolf in his posts, so other than the UTR effect there isnt much to go after him for.
Dont really know if tomorrows wagons are set in stone or not, but I hope we can uncover a real wolf or the SK. With 2 players dieing each day, it can reach endgame very fast so we cant afford to waste a lynch. I am gonna read over the game tonight and hopefully have reads for tommorow. I will be back to cast my vote on corsakh if needed but theres no reason to MAJ night because all it does is deprive us as some communication time until night.
