Okay here's what I found interesting:
#469 doesn't want to vote Jumanji
#477 votes Beer
#555 tone implies that the beer vote is not due to a peek.
#575 Defends Jumanji again
#585 and again.
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
Didn't jumanji remain pretty silent last time he got some heat (in the ssfr game)? His defense, even though it may not sound like hes a villa, makes me not want to vote him today
I also think Jack is playing similar to the first game. Posting a lot and changing his mind a lot. So I don't think we should lynch him for a while either.
As for right now, I'm not sure who to vote.I havent played with WU or beer and don't have a read on either one
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
Firstly, I'd like to apologize for my lolbad vote yesterday. I had a slight inclination towards WU being a villa so I voted for beer. But no justified reason for voting beer. And I see why voting beer with the reason I stated is pretty bad. I don't think hes a wolf at this point, mostly because of what the keshaldra killing tells us. I'll also point out that, if I'm a wolf, that vote would have been suicidal and I would like to think I would make a better wolf than that. But I have not been one yet.
Secondly of all, I think BB brings up a good point. I also read Soah's strat guide about the secondary wolf thing. However, at that point, stark had already gained some attention from posting that list of his. Assuming stark is a wolf, wouldn't pushing that wagon be a little reckless at that point of the game? If stark gets some spite votes out of that list, kesh would have been in a pretty ****ty spot
#1104 first accusation of Ily
Also interesting: ily publically asks for and votes along with Fenix's input
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
I'll give a couple thoughts on some of the players slink mentioned
ily - He has posted 3 times:
This looks pretty wolfy. No content, making excuses about being a noob. Not voting d1 seems like something a noob wolf would do. He also voted Malgin for no clear reason. I don't like the late vote and I don't like the logic behind it.
Malgin - I'm not too sure about him. He could go either way aorn. He has had some wolfy posting but I don't necessarily think hes a wolf. The fact that ily voted him helps his case. We need more info on him before lynching
A Ert - that JD vote then switch to jack looks a wee bit suspicious last night but I can't say much more about him. He voted WU the first day and was in the middle of the pack iirc
I don't have a read on chaser.
GTP mentioned that he thought a lot of the wolves were utr. That makes me think there are some active wolves. I doubt there is more than 1 wolf in this group
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
it looks bad but mrsbutton changed her(?) vote 4 times total yesterday. 3 times the day before. Not out of the ordinary. Ert looks worse imo
#1107
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
I don't mind an A. Ert wagon but I think ilya is more likely to a wolf. I don't like his tone overall. He hasn't posted much of anything. He's been talking about how the game is intimidating but this is not excuse not to post as a villa. His unwillingness to take a stand on anyone bothers me and its something I would think a noob wolf is prone to do. I'm not really liking that d2 vote. Plus a wagon on him might convince him to start posting a bit more which can't be bad.
vote ilya
#1205 Says Ilya's a wolf but doesn't mind an Aert wagon either.
#1257
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
Yea I'm gonna to ahead and unvote ilya. His posts today makes me think he's a villa who doesn't care. But I'm not gonna go as far as to say I'll clear him but I won't vote him today.
#1357 doesn't want a Malgin wagon
#1363 Doesn't like a button wagon so votes Chaser:
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
I don't really like the button wagon either and I'm gonna vote Chaser. I don't have a strong read on him but seems better than the other 2.
#1387 unvotes Malgin votes Button
#1487:
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
This is a pretty good list I think. I have played with Ainex, Jumanji, and Karak before. Ainex was pretty inactive when he was a villa which is similar to what he has been here. Jumanji was a wolf and I will admit, his play is starting to look more like his wolf game now. I was hesitant at first, as you mentioned, but he has decreased his posting and is making some throwaway posts. It's similar to how he stayed utr for a long time in the ssfr game. I wouldn't mind wagoning him today. Karak is a good player and one of the more experienced players here I think. His villa play was not very active in the last game but he probably plays a similar wolf game. I can't really tell about him.
The other players seem like decent choices.
How many people that voted malgin do we think are woofs? This is an interesting list and we should look into this a bit further I think.
I'm thinking 2 maybe even 3. Best candidates including ilya (another horrible vote to his record), riverfenix (not contributing much, was the original creator for the Malgin wagon, joined wagon in a typical wolf spot), and buttons for sporadic and inconsistent voting. Brian is looking as a very likely villa. I also think BB is a villa
#1564 he is suspicious of Fenix and Ilya
#1566
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
Wagoning utr players is obv a better idea. I think JD and Jumanji wagons would be good alternatives. Jumanji especially, his play is really starting to look like his wolf play in the ssfr game. He has a couple posts today so he isn't afk
#1573
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
Yea playing wolf in such a similar way seems odd. He hasn't been active much the past 2 days. Reading through his posts again it seems that most of his reads have been pretty good. He said JF was a villa and was quite adamant about this. He called GTP a wolf. His 2 other biggest wolf leans seem to be nightwolf and brian. I don't know about Brian but nightwolf as a wolf is plausible imo. That wagon has been started a few times and never taken off.
#1592
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
so you're basing your bitchi vote on his comment on lynching for information? It doesn't look like a blatant contradiction btw. I think lynching BB at this point would be pretty bad.
#1731 Suspicious of Fenix and votes him
#1749 Says button wagon is not the best option.
#1762 again says button is not a wolf.
Quote:
Originally Posted by BingoBango
buttons and you would have been a start
unvote
buttons does not look like a wolf here at all anymore to me
#1789 Votes Corsakh
#1793 unvotes votes button
Random posts that are should be n.b.:
#1577 Jumanji's top two wagon choices when bingo asks him are: Brian and Nightwood with button a third choice.
#1247 WER post that is interesting but not really damning:
Quote:
Originally Posted by WinEvryRacex
Chaser/bingo look wolfy to me...Pls to be having these 2 as wagons today.
.
