As I said yesterday I'm not 100% on this yet.

However I have left clues in my posts as to who i think it is and i'm sure y'all can figure it out if I'm sk killed again.

Haha qft.

wtf, did you see the level of discourse on the subject that took place between you getting offed and you coming back? Obviously we don't have a ****ing clue

Excuse me for being ignorant but does this mean card take 2 is def a villager?

Of course card take 2 is a villager.

ok, I just went and read through Chaser (Ya, I know. I'm late)

He goes after corsakh pretty hard, ldo, so he is an easy vote.

Looks like Brian = villager is his other peek?

vote corsakh

didn't think my analysis was to damm confusing

This seems like a horrible decision. It seems Card was killed *specifically* because he thought he knew the SK's role. So either Card is coming back in a villager = SK is fked, or Card is coming back in as a wolf and may lie about what SK's role was = village is fked.

But he says mburke is posting a lot in this thread, which at this stage he hadn't he had made 5 posts.

Also it was chaser's first post of the day.

to me it looks like an inexperienced seer wanting to clear his peek without making it too obvious.

Notice he also defends him d3. None of the times he defends him he uses any logic as to why he is villa, this leads me to believe he knows mburke is vill but can't find any reason in the thread to back it up.

No offence, but I would prefer it if someone else answered the question! Ice?

If card take 2 is a wolf, then the integrity of the game is completely ruined.

Come on it's better than a modkill for sure.

Also I could be way off on the sk.

five posts thus far


find someone else? subtle i know but hey he had to be

Sorry, your post was good...it's still just a confusing situation overall because card's posts could be interpreted in multiple ways.

Yeah it all depends on whether the sk or the wolves killed me.

Better than a modkill for village if you are village.

I think modkill is the fairest way to do it tbh, but I'm village so freeroll imo.

I really can't believe there wasn't another sub available tho, wasn't there a long subbing list? Like MinusEV and a few others.

w/e, the monkey hath ruleth. Now dance monkey, dance.

If it would make people happier, for the integrity of the game I will refrain from making any more comments about who I think the serial killer is.

fyp

OK so I take it that it is possible that Card may be a wolf. Thats pretty fked up if it is true. Would still love confirmation from the Ice man.

If you're a wolf, how is that better for village than a modkill?

************************MOD NOTE****************************

FINDING A REAL SUB WOULD BE TOO DIFFICULT CONSIDERING THIS THREAD IS OVER 1600 POSTS. SO IT WAS EITHER CARDASSIAN OR MOD-KILL AND I THINK THAT SUBBING IS THE LESSER OF TWO EVILS.

i think alot of cards posts were seer cover (saw a trap in there for me in this respect)
but card posts very much like he talks irl and i thought i saw some sk clues throughout his posts. we talked alot of ww strat before i decided to play so i may have some insight into all that. Of course he could be using the fact that we know eachother irl to level me

lol yeah i misread your post there.

Thought you were saying a modkill was better than me subbing back in if I was village.

btw, this kinda goes along with what Brian said a little, but everyone be careful of interpreting cardassian's posts too much in the same vein as we read his old posts. If card is a wolf now (high probability imo since he replaced A.E who we all thought was super wolfy) then he has tons of information now that he didn't have when he made his original posts. Don't let him confuse us by thinking he's the same old villagery card.

Also, if the new card is a wolf, I think there's a very high probability that both jobeen and mburke are also wolves given the above exchange. Nobody's presented this argument before (about chaser saying mburke was posting a lot when he wasn't) until jobeen did it at the start of today (and he even ****ed it up at first by saying it was about mdom and not mburke). It reeks of something that they coordinated together in wolfchat and did a messy job of executing.