ok far enough i can easly vote for the other UTR player tonight if a wagon gets started.

But i am going to like Nightwood again tonight unless he does something crazy to make me change my mind.

Why is no one poasting this weekend?

gsyudfgysuakdgfykuasfghilkhfu I was on page 7 of a analysis of gtpitches actions and I accidentally closed the tab. ARGHERGHEGH

Re-starting, but while I do everybody suspicious of Mrsbuttons check out page 4 before the EOD. There's some funny interactions between her and gtpitch (who she had said on page 3 was a wolf) where she asks his opinions on the WU wagon and states repeatedly that she doesn't like it. It twitched my wolfdar a little.

When I remake my post I'll be more detailed, obv, but I figured I'd throw that out for right now.

i know something about mrsbuttons too.

I just use the pronouns appropriate to whatever the handle is, it makes life so much simpler. If he gets upset at being called a she than he should pick a different name imo

fyi I got the page numbers wrong, the Mrsbutton-gtpitch was on page 5, her wolf read of him on page 4.

Yea I'm gonna to ahead and unvote ilya. His posts today makes me think he's a villa who doesn't care. But I'm not gonna go as far as to say I'll clear him but I won't vote him today.

Any reasoning behind this?

doubt it

Also voting for utr people is bad, kesh advocated it d1

Page by Page gtpitch analysis:

Page 1: Nothing, no posts from him yet.

Page 2: 2 hello posts and a rand vote for goofy, pretty sure that's just d1 craziness and that there's nothing to be read into there. He also has a post whining about how nobody is posting, again pretty bland and info-less.

A couple more fluff posts before we get to post 162 which is his first significant post of the game. He gives three reads, WER-villa, Brian-suspicious, nightwood he tells to stop acting like a wolf. I'm not entirely sure how much we can read into this, but in my experience usually when wolves posts lists of reads they include at least one wolf as a wolf lean. We're pretty sure WER is a villa at this point, and nightwood has been acting villagery so far, which leaves Brian whom I'm still leaning wolf on.

post 193 mdom leaves a fake peek of gtpitch being a villa. I don't think a wolf would ever fake peek another wolf, so villa points to mdom.

post 198 is gtpitch's response to this. I honestly don't know what to make of it yet.

there were a couple more posts, but they didn't look like anything substainal.

Page 3:

Post 226 gtpitch's reaction to starkwoods random list. Nothing much to say here except that this is exactly how I would expect a wolf to react to something like that, just laugh it off and move on.

gtpitch then unvotes and goes afk. Other things of note on this page are O0brians post attacking gtpitch and then voting him (+ villa points)

Page 4:

first mention of gtpitch comes up here where MrsButtons says she finds him suspicious.

Post 384 is gtpitchs response, mainly playing the victim, not a typical villager defense but we already know gt was a wolf so not much to be gained here.

Page 5:

Post 406 deserves scruitiny I think. Gtpitch is trying to minimalize reads based on differences in play between games. I don't think gtpitch makes this post if the people who were being looked at because of this were all villagers, he'd probably just sit back and let us hang each other. Which leads me to believe that somewhere in pages 3 and 4 we found a wolf based on him playing differently than he has in the past, and gtpitch was trying to cover for him. Somebody eventually going back and looking at this would be helpful.

Post 412 he goes after cors a bit, probably villa points to cors but it could easily be a wolf covering himself by going after another wolf. I'm not sure, it may however indicate that a good portion of the wolf team is staying UTR since gtpitch was trying to dissuade us from going after them (well specifically they were afk at that point, but nearly all of them are still UTR now, either way if there are wolves in that group gtpitch didn't want us focusing on them).

Post 422 says he doesn't mind a wraith wagon, not really much to glean out of it.

Post 446 basically leaves me pretty convinced mdom is a villager. Maybe one wolf (kesh) would comment on that interation if it was w-v but two doing it is really unlikely. I don't think it's anything other than v-v there.

Post 463 by Malgin. I thought his EOD voting yesterday was suspicious and this read of gtpitch just looks pretty bad now that we know what gtpitch's role is. I wouldn't expect a good wolf to leave a read like that on a fellow wolf ever, but iirc Malgin is pretty inexperianced and if he is a wolf I wouldn't put it past him.

post 466 is intresting for a couple reasons. One being that MrsButton has gone from a wolf read on gtpitch to asking his opinion in one page, which is odd. Maybe there was a post inbetween where button goes back on her read but I didn't notice it. WRT cors I don't think we get much out of it, tossup really of it being a subtle defense of cors and it just being a wolf being wishy-washy.

Post 471 Weird post by buttons since they were discussing a cors wagon and not the WU wagon. Buttons says that she doesn't like the WU wagon repeatedly later on, not gonna quote it since it'd just be repitition.

Post 474 again weird interaction between buttons and gtpitch. It could easily be gtpitch trying to tell a fellow wolf to stop acting like a tard, or gtpitch just sowing confusion by putting suspicion on another villager. No real way to tell.

gtp ends up voting WU for the lynch.

I've been at this for over an hour thanks to me deleting my 1st one, I'm getting something to eat and will follow up with the next day.

lol .. coming out of nowhere with some serious business yes? plz find a real wolf now

for the moment i'll go with chaser

and malgin ..considering your post i quoted above - you are either a dumb villager or a dumb wolf. you didn't seem quite dumb in our last game, sooo ... get where i am aiming?

explain to me how I'm wolfish

Can we stop with the "page # X" references since not everyone is on the same posts/page settings? Post numbers are fine.

the malgin vote on nightwood out of nowhere is similar to his last two votes coming out of nowhere to get on JF/JD and sketches me out.

is there any reason we shouldn't be all up on your grill malgin?

yeah sorry, links to it are in my post.

and fwiw i think nw train tonight is horribly bad

dude, you are so wolfish it reeks. you want to tell me you've forgotten about our little interaction not even 24hrs ago - where i exactly explained why i think you're wolfy?

now for anybody elses convenience

http://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/sh...postcount=1187

plz to be reading 1187-189

hmm

fwiw, at least todai won't vote for you. apart from there being a lot better targets - awesome bump for that bbv thread

nightwood that argument is terrible, because I think the wolves were seer hunting does not make me a wolf... Your other arguments I believe I refuted.

VN post DJ, I'm going to look into malgin closely, his actions + this post is rediculous.

Jumanji is either a diehard wolf or a total newb and therefore of no use to the village.

I don't like the Beer vote, but then, he's not being much help either.

As always, UTR means that you pee on trees.

gtpitch smells good to me, if for no other reason than I'd like to keep his avatar around a while longer. Villa lean.

WoW

That should be in a quote box obv, I suck at foruming

lollercoaster

- i explain why you are wolfy
- you don't answer

- a couple of hours later you ask me why i think you are wolfy

- of course all arguments have alreadybeen refuted (sorry, must have missed that)

i see no reason for changing my vote atm

/lollercoaster