J.D. would be a wolf if it weren't for the fact that gtpitch wanted to wagon him at EOD. J.D. you have some splainin to do though.

Karak is still a wolf.

gtpitch definitely spewed a lot, the question is how he went about it. He buddied up to me and urged everyone not to vote me, and I'm villa. However he also defended Karak early and Karak's a woof woof.

A.Ertbjerg and Ilya wagons are good with me, along with Mrsbuttons. IIRC Buttons was one of our suspects for making the dnkyhunter NK, and yeah, her pushing me/nightwood all day yesterday was suspicious.

Caedus was a seerhunt, if they aren't hunting seers they have no shot at winning.

@ WER: I still think I'm right about the SK - you say that SK has to fear wolves more than villagers, so he should wolfhunt. However he shouldn't fear wolves at all, bc wolves aren't going to NK him unless he leaves fakepeeks. However, obviously he feels differently so highfive to him for wolfhunting.

I think it's pretty horrible that we let me and J.F. flip yesterday. I was indifferent on J.F. but according to others he plays an aggro villa game, and that's not the type of person you want to be lynching early. Same goes for me.

I'm never voting cardassian.

vote A.Ertbjerg

This is very interesting as when the wagons where 4 Brian/3J.F./3J.D. GT choose J.D., definately makes J.D. far more villagery.

Ok so about wagoning me. Why?

I voted for the guy that nobody was voting for because as Fenix I think said, neither options that were being wagoned made any sense to me personally.

I didn't see any reason to vote either way so I just sided with a dude who was outspoken yet seemed smart and didn't affect the outcome of the voting process.

In other words - I tried to remain neutral, and am going to continue to do so until I have some heavy reasons to do otherwise. I don't get this game, seems a lot of finger pointing in every direction, so vote me out if you'd like, I don't have any tone reads or any of that to offer


Btw, it'd be funny to have a thread where there are no actual wolves, only the mod playing along and see how many people lose their **** plotting all sorts of elaborate tone reads and game analysis Perhaps on the next April Fools?

Ilya please then enlighten me on your opinions on the game. Or shall you just scan whats going on and post nothing like a wolf would do.

I don't mind an A. Ert wagon but I think ilya is more likely to a wolf. I don't like his tone overall. He hasn't posted much of anything. He's been talking about how the game is intimidating but this is not excuse not to post as a villa. His unwillingness to take a stand on anyone bothers me and its something I would think a noob wolf is prone to do. I'm not really liking that d2 vote. Plus a wagon on him might convince him to start posting a bit more which can't be bad.

vote ilya

jeez thats like the third time someone has posted something significant while I'm writing a post. But its not gonna make me change my vote

Saying you voted just for the sake of voting doesn't make you look any better. Why did you even vote at all in that case? Trying to remain neutral is not a good thing

I thought voting was mandatory? I would've opted not to vote or participate in the first 2 days of random accusations if it were an option

Why's being neutral not a good thing? Goes against all I've been taught about life

if everyone is neutral, the wolves win. It's not helpful attribute in this game. So, as slink asked, can you give us some thoughts on players please?

Also, editing posts is not allowed.

And afaik, voting is not mandatory yet but usually becomes mandatory as the game progresses

************MOD NOTE************

EDITING POSTS IS STRICTLY FORBIDDEN

IlyaMuromec YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED NEXT TIME WILL BE A MODKILL

DUE TO THE SERIOUSNESS OF THIS OFFENSE IlyaMuromec IS NOT ALLOWED TO USE ANY VOWELS FOR THE REMAINDER OF THE DAY. 1340 CAN BE USED AS REPLACEMENTS.

DO NOT EDIT POSTS

TY THAT IS ALL

************MOD NOTE************

oops?

*******MOD NOTE*********

ARE THOSE VOWELS????????

NO MORE VOWELS TODAY FOR YOU!!!!!!!

0h. 0k 1 r3s1gn fr0m p0st1ng t0d@y th3n. l@t3r

hahahahhaha OTI is the best mod ever

and i think in hindsight based on ilya's last 2 posts he looks more like an ignorant villa than an utr wolf.

unvote
vote Mrsbutton

Upon rereading, Mrsbutton did very typical "wolf gaining villa points" on Day 1 by saying that she didn't like either wagon (but without giving reasoning). Most wolves' inclination when they see a villager about to get lynched is to say, "I really don't like that wagon!". Nightwood pointed this out in Post 558, so huge villa points to him when Mrsbutton comes back wolf.

Here are the posts for reference:

It really doesn't surprise me that Mrsbutton has come after Nightwood for exposing her out like that. Or for me b/c I've got one of her wolfbuddies.

[1] A.Ertbjerg-
[0] Ainex-mdom
[0] BingoBango-ilya
[0] BitchiBee-
[0] Brian -buttons
[0] cardassian -mburke
[0] chaser1942-
[0] corsakh -
[0] djstu -mburke
[0] goofyballer-mburke
[0] I_Like_Beer-
[1] IlyaMuromec
[0] jobeen-
[0] JumanjiBoard -nightwood
[0] Karak567 –
[0] Malgin-
[4] mburke05-
[1] mdom88 -mburke
[1] Mrsbutton-
[1] nightwood-
[0] O0Brian0O-
[0] RiverFenix-
[0] J.D.(For saymond)-
[0] Slink-a.e
[0] starkwired -
[0] WinEvryRacex -

enough...

I told you guys that you need to lynch the people that SMELL wolfy...

nightwood does not give me night or wood....

vote nightwood

mrsbutton, please explain the italicized statements above...

lol i'm stupid it's all italicized when quoting

explain what you said about card/jobeen/beer more in depth please

why?

quick thoughts on people that stand out:

lean villa:

goofy- the list he posted he would not do as a wolf...he could be SK though
WER- overall tone, reaction to players nominated thus far def seems villagery
corsakh- typical ******ation, but I suppose he could just be covering
nightwood- the people going after him seem super suspicious

lean wolf:

mrsbutton- weird statements, accusations flown for little reason, brian made some good points about this above
malgin- same as above, bandwagon of nightwood
mburke- wtf is he doing, very different play from SSNL game when he was villa, snap attacking goofy again looked funny at first, but the way it played out seems suspicious


I think one of mrsbutton/malgin/nightwood has to be a wolf, and possibly two. We should start there.

Why did I vote for Brian? He keeps emphatically stating that he is 100% SURE I am a wolf, which means one of two things. He's either being unbelievably foolish and is playing the game with blinders on, or he is trying to press a wagon on me (meaning he is a wolf). I just couldn't bring myself to believe that he was playing with blinders on, but I guess he was. He could still be a wolf, but probably not.

Why did I vote for JF late? Because Caedus told me to. I even said that when I voted. I was very sure he was a villa, and I always trust his reads when I play WW with him (as long as I am sure he is a villa).

I still don't think nightwood is a great wagon, and I will only vote for him today if I have to do so in the cause of self-preservation.

Mburke is an ok wagon, and, as I said before, I do not believe Brian is a good wagon anymore.

JD, why are you so utr this game?

Brian, why would it matter what you think? There's absolutely no reason to try to encourage the sk to go after village.....what are you doing? And yes, he does have to fear the wolves more. Maybe not today, but for a long-term plan he needs to side with village.