Ok guys, first thank you for taking it easy on me and not making me read 50 pages like you did last night
Second, Chaser. I could not really put my hands on what was wrong with you about this Cadeus situation, but then it hit me. Despite having played so much werewolf, most of your games were turbos. And you are just as noob as most of us when it comes to some aspects of the long games.
I will try to break it down to you in small easy steps. Please just put you "kill corsakh" goggles down for a second and bear with me. You can put them back on later after I finish, its ok with me, its not the point I am tryign to make. I just want try to explain the Cadeus situation one more time so that we don't have to come back to this again in the future.
Ok, so you are used to playing turbos. In turbos you have:
- usually a handful of people who know each other pretty well
- usually one or two seers
- usually n0 peek
- the whole game usually lasts only a few days
- almost every myslinch is critical
Sure, I understand. People start seer hunting from the get go and seers are often to come out on the second and sometimes even first day.
Guess what. Almost none of this is true for a long game we are playing.
Lets assess your assumption for a second that Cadeus kill was a seer hunt. Possbile? Absolutely. Likely? Um, lets look at it.
First lets think about d0.
Seers did not receive a night pick, so there is not much to fish around apart from maybe posting tendencies. Who got killed n1? Dnky. Arguably one of the best and most experienced players in the game. What does it tell us? One, pups are killing experienced players. Two, pups are probably at least mildly competent.
Anyway, lets move on to the following day. Caedus gets subbed. Likely the most experienced player in the game. Immediately drops a bomb on me, later admits he did not like my tone and is hunting for a SK. Gets NK'ed. Is this consistent with what we learned form d0, that pups are after experienced players and have some sort of a clue? Yes. If I were not clean, would I be worried about Cadeus pushing on me? Of course. Would it be the drigin force behind the kill? Probably not.
There are some more things to consider. For one, its no secret that the first days in a 32 man game are a complete cluster**** and looking for a seer, especially one who only has one peek and who may or may not have posted a peek yet is like looking for a needle in a haystack.
Second, Cadeus was subbed during the night and OTI has said all role people were available for night action. This means if Cadeus was a seer, he made his pick - it was not randed. Then if his claim that he saw a SK in me is correct, why the hell would he waste a pick on me? And if he thought I was a pup and lied about the SK part, why would he pick me anyway? Just think about, are not there better picks to make on the first night than me?
And lastly, you also gotta understand that Cadeus is a smart and experienced player. And as such he should understand that his chances of dying immediately after getting subbed and after seeing dnky die on the first night, are pretty high. I am not even sure how, but there is chance is he was a seer he would try a little harder ton contribute or maybe play less careless. And might had even come out on at the end of the day hoping pups will not believe and roleblock him, or whatever its called.
Of course not a fact that any of these even occurred top the pups, but there is a chance that it did. Some of this may sound biased to you or not, but honestly I did give my best trying to explain it. And regardless of what you think I am, I just to wanted to accentuate that Cadeus NK was not seer based and hence we should not try to suck out too much information from it. The only things we know is that he had a negative lean on me and a positive on goofy, but we know it without the NK. That was long, but thank you for attnetion. If you don't agree with any of these its fine, think about it. Ask village. Even though about the only two people that I trust right now are card and mdom, one of which agrees with this and one who does not. Pretty ironic if you ask me
But anyway peace, if you have anything to ask please fire. If you still think wofly about me, its fine. But please don't use the "Caedus nk" logic on me any more, I proably wont find what else to say anyway
Oh and I remember you mentioned me asking questions. Ye, I understand I like asking questions. You also gotta take it into relation of the amount of content someone contributes. Even look at your own posts for example and note how many questions you have asked yourself against what you have contributed, its something that sometimes its hard to notice on others but not on yourself. Like I noticed the same thing on card, only realizing I do very much similar after you pointed it out. Plus I monitor the thread in real time when I study or play and its only natural to ask a question or two here an there.
Anyway peace and good luck
I will stay online for a little while and then should be back before the end of the day.