Two posts above I was responding to card/mdom about Beer.

continuing along this line of thought what do you make of karak's vote on beer yesterday?
Was 4th on his wagon iirc based on beer's wolf list post.

Hello again guys: Here's my idea on things so far after my first proper analysis. There is a lot of noise about ITT but my basic leanings are:

VILLAS

BEER, MDOM, STARK: Mostly because Kershardla went after them D1 and was a wolf.

NIGHTWOOD: Said dnky was a villa today when he was already dead. Would have to be a pretty good level if it came from a wolf who nkilled him.

LEAN VILLA

BITCHIE BEE: Tone only.

CORSARK: Good Helpful Villa Posts.



LEAN WOLF

WER: Defended by Kesh before his wolfy death. But otherwise posts are very helpful to the village so could be ok.

Bingo Bango: For voting Beer D1.

Malgin: For turning up very late D1 and voting with no real reason.

Djstu: All his accusations d1 were against villa like people (beer, stark, WU). fishy, but could just be confused d1 villa.

Mrs button: All over the place at the end of d1. Felt like he jumped on WU but jumped off quick when it looked like he was lynched to avoid looking suspicious.

NO IDEA: Everyone else.

I am looking forward to day 3 or 4 where we can really look closer at who goes and why.

Um, Card, you are asking a lot more questions than I remember you doing.

Ok basically just got up and reading everything since EOD yesterday.

First I'd like to say that looking back I hate my vote on WU but there really wasn't much better. When I started writing my big long post there was only like 2 - 3 votes on him. When I saw I made like 7 or 8 it was too late... A wolf wagon wouldn't have gotten that much steam and I think some of the later votes might be wolf candidates.

I'm a little confused by the SK kill but I think it was probably mostly random and I doubt it had a lot of sound logic to it. Still... I'm not sure why kill Kesh. At any rate if he (or she) wants to take out the other 4 wolves then that'd be fine by me!

I think i'm probably just posting more than I normally do.
Was actually thinking pregame how I should go more tag and not ramble so much, but got into the thread and rambled.

But you're right I should be speaking my mind more and asking questions less, was really only asking because it was your point that made me think of it.

I think Karak's actions yesterday were a bit wolfy.
His using beer's list as a reason to vote him looked like an excuse to me.
Also he defended jobeen's vote on beer and then jumped on the wagon.
This looks like a wolf defending his actions before making them imo.
So for now

Karak

orly ?

FMP

Fixed. Oops - I fail. Was thinking of a different game that I was in with 5 wolves. Actually it was the SSFR game that I modded.

I think I'll add a villa point to your score in my book.

Is that so, sir? You played two games with him, one long and a turbo just a few days ago. I thought you might have some sort of insight.

with kesh or with the serial killer?

wait wat.

i was a villager, and i voted for you consistently with sound logic for doing so and you ended up being a wolf. you didn't post the entire day (just like in the SSNL game). how does that make my action wolfish? further, how is your action not in direct conflict with your last statement given you posted once in 2 days?

Is this true goofy? You're accusing him of being a villager voting for a wolf constantly?

I don't follow your logic that the SK would kill someone just because they played together before. Explain please?

i def agree w/ this. and i don't think beer has put forward anybody that would help us find a group of wolves even if he was one. it would be a stretch to say the least.

and i can respect that you have work goofy, just don't be a hypocrite about it and give me **** for not contributing when i did, with work.

QFIwannaknowthistoo

ok took some advice from yeserday and took notice of a few select players, so far im finding jack frosts random **** flinging a bit wierd and aggressive. all tho this could just be part of his game. someone did mention this was so earlier but only because jack hadn't been flinging much at all. at which time jack started to attack random people. personaly i found this a bit suspect like someone had pointed out a tell and he ajusted. (see post #302)

jumanji's vote for wrath in the last 4 minutes was a bit suspect in my eye's but have'nt look to deaply into that yet i wiil look into it more now but just wanted to put it out there.

meant 4 mintutes before night was called

lol. I looked into this and yeah it's true.

mburke voted for goofy every day and goofy was a wolf.

However to be fair mburke didn't use a lot of reasoning the first couple of days in regards to it.

Could be a sick read (like felix has on me) or it could be that mburke just likes voting goofy, guess we'll have to wait and see.

god so many spelling mistakes in that post i suck at typing

I wouldn't read too much into this tbh.
If the wagons were v-v yesterday then late voting and switching doesn't mean a lot.

First, gj getting Keshaldra, serial killer. Kesh comes across as wolfy mcwolfenstein and I actually was planning on not voting him for a while just bc he's always going to look wolf to me. But Serial Killer definitely either:

1) Went for whom he thought was a lilkely wolf, or,
2) Killed at random.

No offense to Kesh but I doubt he was killed because SK thought he was a strong player.

My guess would be that SK's plan is to stay somewhat UTR, but not so much so that he becomes the target of wagons. His game plan is probably to get peeked, judging by how he went for a wolf, and try to maintain equilibrium during the game. We'll have to see who he kills tomorrow to confirm though, but my guess is he goes for a strong, vocal villie tonight.

Soulread: WinEvryRacex is villager. Win wears his soul on his sleeve though.

Villa lean: cardassian - tho I've never seen card be this vocal; his wolf game was pretty transparent.

Wolf lean: BitchiBee, JumanjiBoard, A.Ertbjerg, BingoBango. I'd say 2/4 of these are wolves.

Wolfie: djstu - went along with Kesh's ILB wagon suggestion. Both of them suggesting it was a good wagon but not voting till after starkwired started the wagon. He also suggests a wolfy strat that would help expose RedRanger.
Wolfie: Karak567 - lynch this man at some point pls.

corsakh probably has to go at some point; guarantee you'll all think he's a wolf at one time or another, but in general he spreads mass confusion and bad ideas. He's already started in this game by suggesting we lynch an AFK Day 1. I have a villa lean on him for now but dude, pls not be tarding up this game.

Cleared from NK's: I_Like_Beer. And trust me he's not a wolf this game.

Really sucks we didn't get tri-wagons going yesterday. Sucks even more that we had v-v wagons, so we aren't gonna learn much. Wolves prob didn't push either wagon yesterday, and maybe a few tossed in a vote so they look like they are participating, but I'd be willing to bet that half of them had random votes or no vote at all. Also, since it seems that the wagons were v/v, a good wolf strategy would have been to push leave their vote on random wagons, as this would help to out the Red Ranger.

I'm gonna post a review of all 3 dead players in a minute, but first to continue the Star Trek discussion: ST: Enterprise is so good Season 3-4, esp 4.

My initial impression was it was more of an emotional vote, trying to protect a newbie (jobeen) from Beers accusations.

It could of been but i'll leave my vote there until i hear something from him.